Are Massive Roots A Good Thing?

  • Thread starter PhatNuggz
  • Start date
  • Tagged users None
PhatNuggz

PhatNuggz

2,121
163
According to a college course book "Hydroponics, A Practical Guide for the Soilless Grower" NO.

Long before getting this book I was amazed at how small my root mass to harvested plant size was

Another point they make is roots should not be fat and coarse (like spaghetti strings) Plants want tons of root hairs, which is where the actual nutrient uptake happens

I have posted pics of 2 plants that I harvested today with root pics from the one of them; the other was similar. That's a 3" net pot

 
Are massive roots a good thing
Are massive roots a good thing 2
Are massive roots a good thing 3
Are massive roots a good thing 4
Are massive roots a good thing 5
h4ppyf4rmer

h4ppyf4rmer

863
143
in my humble opinion, I think it depends on the size of your plant. I grow fairly large plants (4 foot+) to keep my plant count down and my root balls pretty much fill a 5-gallon bucket with a few really fat roots and a metric crap ton of finer roots.

and if your hydro book is for generic hydro(not just cannabis), it also depends on the type of plant in the system...
 
PhatNuggz

PhatNuggz

2,121
163
So much antiquated information gets passed down as truth, like veg 18/6, flower @ 12/12 for bloom. It's a guide, that's all. some 30years ago the big 3 tried to convince congress that improving fuel economy was virtually impossible, LED lighting would never replace MH/HPS, and so on

I neglected to take a root mass picture of this 3ft plant that I transplanted from my bubbler to my F & D 3 days ago. It was ~ softball size. IF you few were right then the root mass should have been at least twice as big

IMG 3972
IMG 3973
 
fatawa

fatawa

1,664
263
No offense nuggz.i kno im right.tall doesnt mean much bro.sure u say its 3 ft tall but it isnt even over a ft wide??i get 6-8zips a plant on average on 3 wk veg.mine r 4Ɨ4wide,n they get massive roots.i usualy end in a 18gal tote cuz 10gal aint deep enough.
 
fatawa

fatawa

1,664
263
20170825 104210 1
20170825 104302 1
Heres a lil example.this is 3wk from bean.still n veg bout to flip her.if u wud start focusing on growing roots n not plant u will really improve.i do this to make a living,its what i do not just a hobby.if u dont belive me double yur tote size once roots touch bottom of yur normal one.bet u you wud b thanking me homie.
 
DemonTrich

DemonTrich

6,394
313
Like the ole saying, bigger roots = bigger fruits.

Those are pretty dark roots for a hydro setup. Imo, should be a lot whiter. Unless the pic was taken days after chop and the roots got dried out.
 
PhatNuggz

PhatNuggz

2,121
163
Here's similar pheno using the same hardware. The Cube is 19"on center. Produced ~ 3/4 pound
As I am not a commercial grower, I try to keep things efficient. Bigger plants means bigger everything.

I did grow with HPA in a 2 x 4 x 2.5 root chamber, but did not see appreciably larger plants.

Looks like you have a large air gap between the large roots and the root hair mass. I have barley have any similarly large roots with minimal separation between. Seems like tightening that up would pay dividends


 
IMG 3714
IMG 3715
fatawa

fatawa

1,664
263
The Cube is 19"on center. Produced ~ 3/4 pound
u got pics wen it was .75 peter?pics dnt always do justice but id gues bout 3zips on that wen it finishes dry(at best).but its pretty much common sense u wud get bigger plants n bigger pots.
 
Last edited:
MW7945

MW7945

3,269
263
Your plants are stretching cause your light source sucks. Not sure why anyone would prefer a smaller root system I guess...
 
Rootbound

Rootbound

Supporter
2,634
263
Here's similar pheno using the same hardware. The Cube is 19"on center. Produced ~ 3/4 pound
As I am not a commercial grower, I try to keep things efficient. Bigger plants means bigger everything.

I did grow with HPA in a 2 x 4 x 2.5 root chamber, but did not see appreciably larger plants.

Looks like you have a large air gap between the large roots and the root hair mass. I have barley have any similarly large roots with minimal separation between. Seems like tightening that up would pay dividends

Umm, you are saying the plant in that pic yielded 12 dry oz??? lol.
 
Jmaes Mabley

Jmaes Mabley

675
143
While I grow in Promix BX and 20 gallon containers. My 20 gallon pots/plants are rootbound by the time 60-70 days of flowering time comes around.

Main strains are Mr Nice SSH, Original Barneys Farm Non Fem G13 x Haze.

I veg in 5g x 1000w Hortilux HPS color corrected with blue.

I flower with 1 x 1000w Hortilux x 1 or 2 20g containers ect, and I transplant the day they go into 12/12. They are totally root bound at the end. I can even put smaller plants in 20g containers, and run 2 per light, and they will still use up all of a 20g container. Im getting around .9g per watt. No CO2. Only fresh air, and several fans. This would also be more in the cooler months, and in the summer I have no heat control, and turn 1 of the 2 lights off

1 plant will also fill up a 30g container if given the opportunity, and lots of light. Not all plants will get a root system like that though, but many will.
 
Jmaes Mabley

Jmaes Mabley

675
143
Nice looking babies. Green all the way down, and no signs of stress, at all. Really Healthy.
 
Organikz

Organikz

3,562
263
Nice looking babies. Green all the way down, and no signs of stress, at all. Really Healthy.
Thank you. The one sativa heavy girl is a little fussy. I had them in 4g nursery pots and they were were out of room. Can't say I'm 100% yet. Still some dialing in to do. Just overwatered with the damn blumat.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Top Bottom