• Home
  • Forums
  • Site Happenings
  • Introduce Yourself
  • Hello, quest to grow with no inputs

Hello, quest to grow with no inputs

  • Thread starter Thread starter YesterdaysHero73
  • Start date Start date Feb 17, 2025
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Hello, quest to grow with no inputs

YesterdaysHero73 Feb 17, 2025 77 Replies 7,276 Views
Page 4 of 4 · Replies 61–78 of 78
Prev
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
First Prev 4 of 4

YesterdaysHero73

Posts
37
Reactions
31
Joined
Feb 17, 2025
Points
18
Apr 24, 2025
#61
Oldchucky said:
Good luck! All of the outdoor cats coming out of hibernation!
Click to expand...
You didn't have to come by to be mean man, just move on to the next thing if this ain't your thing
 
Reactions: Greenadian, Bobcat.Branch, TheGoldenRoad and 1 other person
Quote Reply

Oldchucky

Supporter
Posts
14,756
Reactions
50,130
Joined
May 4, 2021
Points
438
Apr 24, 2025
#62
YesterdaysHero73 said:
You didn't have to come by to be mean man, just move on to the next thing if this ain't your thing
Click to expand...
What the hell is mean about that? I’m coming out of hibernation myself! All right, I’ll move on! No problem! Good luck!
 
Reactions: GNick55, Greenadian, Bobcat.Branch and 1 other person
Quote Reply
G

Glomus

Posts
323
Reactions
347
Joined
Sep 7, 2022
Points
63
Apr 24, 2025
#63
YesterdaysHero73 said:
Thank you for the information
It's just this is exactly what I do not want to do. Soil test won't be done until I can afford some micro eyes! Which I'm very excited for.


So just to be clear 100% closed loop natural. :)

I'm looking for advice in this department. Tanks!
Click to expand...
What does your compost consist of? like what kind of plant material and type of plant mass in particular? Also do you have any live stock or manure you are planning to use? Are you planing on using your own human manure since your going native lol?
 
Reactions: GNick55
Quote Reply

TheGoldenRoad

Supporter
If the bus comes by, get on ✌️
Posts
3,954
Reactions
15,160
Joined
Jul 17, 2024
Points
263
Apr 24, 2025
#64
YesterdaysHero73 said:
Untouched since the early 1900's even then it was a mine! Pretty stoked! Literally dirt cheap!
Click to expand...
Dude I’m envious.
 
Reactions: GNick55
Quote Reply

TheGoldenRoad

Supporter
If the bus comes by, get on ✌️
Posts
3,954
Reactions
15,160
Joined
Jul 17, 2024
Points
263
Apr 24, 2025
#65
YesterdaysHero73 said:
You didn't have to come by to be mean man, just move on to the next thing if this ain't your thing
Click to expand...
Chucky didn’t mean that in a mean way man. We’re all excited to be starting the outdoor season. Happy growing
 
Reactions: GNick55, Grownsince95, Greenadian and 1 other person
Quote Reply

Bobcat.Branch

Posts
1,170
Reactions
3,403
Joined
Feb 11, 2025
Points
263
Apr 25, 2025
#66
YesterdaysHero73 said:
You didn't have to come by to be mean man, just move on to the next thing if this ain't your thing
Click to expand...



The tone was set in the very beginning...

Im on my second season (starting april), I want to grow all natural with only inputs bright water. I'm not dumb so please, I do not need any bragarts hating.
Click to expand...

Some just go looking for it, I guess.
 
Reactions: Coconutz, GNick55, Grownsince95 and 1 other person
Quote Reply

Jimmie

Posts
982
Reactions
3,967
Joined
Sep 6, 2021
Points
243
Apr 25, 2025
#67
YesterdaysHero73 said:
You didn't have to come by to be mean man, just move on to the next thing if this ain't your thing
Click to expand...
Old Chucky is the nicest guy on here, I’ve never seen him disrespect or disparage anyone. He’s a guy you should embrace for knowledge.
 
Reactions: GNick55, Grownsince95, YesterdaysHero73 and 2 others
Quote Reply

YesterdaysHero73

Posts
37
Reactions
31
Joined
Feb 17, 2025
Points
18
Apr 25, 2025
#68
Understood, i may have heard his comment in a way that was not intended.
 
Reactions: GNick55 and Grownsince95
Quote Reply

Newty

Supporter
15% Off Fast Buds Orders, Code: NEWTY42
Posts
2,152
Reactions
5,544
Joined
Feb 4, 2024
Points
263
Apr 25, 2025
#69
Idk if I understand "no input" growing.

What I'm thinking is you want to grow with all organic material, no synthetic or salt based nutrients?
You want to be able to plant your crop and not have to worry about adding anything throughout the grow but water?

If that's the case then you want to add products that are OMRI, NOP, or ROC certified.
These are certifications given to organic medium and other ammendment.
 
Reactions: GNick55 and YesterdaysHero73
Quote Reply

YesterdaysHero73

Posts
37
Reactions
31
Joined
Feb 17, 2025
Points
18
Apr 25, 2025
#70
Newty said:
Idk if I understand "no input" growing.

What I'm thinking is you want to grow with all organic material, no synthetic or salt based nutrients?
You want to be able to plant your crop and not have to worry about adding anything throughout the grow but water?

If that's the case then you want to add products that are OMRI, NOP, or ROC certified.
These are certifications given to organic medium and other ammendment.
Click to expand...
Appreciate your "input" lol

Yes I'm growing in natural soil, 2" of my own closed loop copost mixed in. That's it. No inputs other then creek water:)
 
Reactions: RoadKillSkunkHunt and GNick55
Quote Reply

JIMKSI64

Posts
4,220
Reactions
14,337
Joined
Apr 21, 2025
Points
263
Apr 25, 2025
#71
Bobcat.Branch said:
View attachment 2421466

The tone was set in the very beginning...



Some just go looking for it, I guess.
Click to expand...
Literally I found this thread and hit back after reading the first panel. When I clicked it old Chucky's post came up and I was like hey I read everything he posts so I went to Chucky's and saw I was so right.
 
Reactions: GNick55
Quote Reply

ATLien415

Posts
80
Reactions
112
Joined
Apr 6, 2025
Points
33
Apr 25, 2025
#72
You still have inputs, there is no such thing as 'no input' farming. Inputs always drive a system, Archimedean principle and what not. Like the creek water is a source of a plethora of inputs. Your compost as well. Potentially even your seedstock, might have endophytes present and be another input.

I see what you're going for though and the terminology would be 'closed-loop- or regenerative'. Would recommend to throw some alphalpha in as a companion crop for triacontanol . Long-term living soil is a different beast all together. When your scope is keeping a bed on point for 5, 10, 15 years means hitting up soil analysis bros. The timelines for companion crops to break down to pieces that matter is multiple cycles. You'd have to ask a soil pro but I imagine you're planning 5+ cycles away when you plant a companion crop today. Often, keeping beds for that amount of time requires synthetic amendments at times (at least according to the KiS guys and his PHD/academic network of scientists who specialize in soil).

Also, ferments are the cutting edge in regenerative cannabis cultivation. Save every molecule of plant matter and ferment it. Basically the humic/fulvic principles taken to the next level. Sounds like you are already doing this in the form of your closed loop mulch/fertilizer input.
 
Reactions: GNick55 and YesterdaysHero73
Quote Reply

YesterdaysHero73

Posts
37
Reactions
31
Joined
Feb 17, 2025
Points
18
Apr 25, 2025
#73
ATLien415 said:
You still have inputs, there is no such thing as 'no input' farming. Inputs always drive a system, Archimedean principle and what not. Like the creek water is a source of a plethora of inputs. Your compost as well. Potentially even your seedstock, might have endophytes present and be another input.

I see what you're going for though and the terminology would be 'closed-loop- or regenerative'. Would recommend to throw some alphalpha in as a companion crop for triacontanol . Long-term living soil is a different beast all together. When your scope is keeping a bed on point for 5, 10, 15 years means hitting up soil analysis bros. The timelines for companion crops to break down to pieces that matter is multiple cycles. You'd have to ask a soil pro but I imagine you're planning 5+ cycles away when you plant a companion crop today. Often, keeping beds for that amount of time requires synthetic amendments at times (at least according to the KiS guys and his PHD/academic network of scientists who specialize in soil).

Also, ferments are the cutting edge in regenerative cannabis cultivation. Save every molecule of plant matter and ferment it. Basically the humic/fulvic principles taken to the next level. Sounds like you are already doing this in the form of your closed loop mulch/fertilizer input.
Click to expand...
I appreciate your advice!

I do have something to offer you for that tho. What if there were no humans? Would plants grow? In my opinion yes!

So cycles, yes companions do not create compostable material for at least 1 season--- except roots, roots will begin as soon as the plant is terminated however, brassica, legume, and most prairie grass covers will fix nitrogen. A diverse, as possible, mix of covers will expand the nutes beyond N. I have looked into the Koreans method of fermenting, it does not interest me.

!st time with a divers companion mix, and I sowed green so I'm very excited!

thanks again for your advice :)
 
Last edited: Apr 25, 2025
Reactions: ATLien415
Quote Reply

ATLien415

Posts
80
Reactions
112
Joined
Apr 6, 2025
Points
33
Apr 27, 2025
#74
YesterdaysHero73 said:
I appreciate your advice!

I do have something to offer you for that tho. What if there were no humans? Would plants grow? In my opinion yes!

So cycles, yes companions do not create compostable material for at least 1 season--- except roots, roots will begin as soon as the plant is terminated however, brassica, legume, and most prairie grass covers will fix nitrogen. A diverse, as possible, mix of covers will expand the nutes beyond N. I have looked into the Koreans method of fermenting, it does not interest me.

!st time with a divers companion mix, and I sowed green so I'm very excited!

thanks again for your advice :)
Click to expand...
Astute point, I agree. The plants would certainly grow if we vanished. They would flourish. The only thing is that they would grow and flourish in a much different way than we use the plant. You would see re-naturalizing occur, the vast majority of cultivars go extinct, the prioritization of lanky growth and low-moisture pollen and intersex sites and more. It would basically be everything we love about the plant but in reverse. The plant as we know it is by definition intertwined with it's stewardship and alterations by humans.

My point is that doing a living soil web can be really tricky at scale. Organic apple farms have largely succumbed to using non-organic foliar sprays (practically required to be profitable in the industry). Depending on your crop, running a 1200 or 280000 acre site might mean that you're regularly applying rock for phosphorous - that is a slow process. Unless you started before we started farming, you're likely going to need a one or two time synthetic application. Water sources may entirely preclude certain micros based on water metrics, requiring intervention with presumed synthetics or remediating the water source. Potassium is another that is driven hard in some crops and can be tricky to give back at scale. The entire point of going closed-loop is to be able to scale, right? If it isn't scalable then it is pointless for the end goal of being better stewards for our planet.

I make the argument that the majority of micros (unless you're doing something truly closed loop like mostly using self-derived-ferments or farm animal compost for inputs) should be synthetic for folks. Bo, Mo, Co and such are tricky for organic inputs! Basically all micros are tricky unless you have a living animal's feces (after feeding it a plethora of inputs) or synthetics or centuries to wait. I think this is one of the arguments for ferments. I know the folks at Grease have shown some truly wild stuff with the humic/fulvics. Basically, if you give the plant a partially formed terpene or flavorant or cannabinoid or a derivative product, the plant is able to discern this and will take the path of least energy to form it's own (aka takes the building blocks up). Between that and the entire fact that many of the humic/fulvics can actually be home to microbial life as well, ferments are definitely the future (no matter what name or method they end up being associated with).

Another really good point that I never really thought of. Being how easy free salt transport is across root tissue, the reverse is also going to be true when it comes to decomposition. Mind gears are moving. :D I love what you're doing. Can't wait for the pics.
 
Reactions: YesterdaysHero73
Quote Reply

voltage

Posts
902
Reactions
2,903
Joined
Nov 11, 2023
Points
243
Apr 27, 2025
#75
LoveGrowingIt said:
No worries. I just thought it was interesting that THC Farmer was the best they had.


Sounds good. This is how farming was done for a very long time.
Click to expand...
Still is. Heh

North Koreans fight over feces as annual ‘compost battle’ begins

Impossible government quotas make people turn violent as they try to get enough poop to make fertilizer.
www.rfa.org
 
Quote Reply

RoadKillSkunkHunt

Posts
1,284
Reactions
2,417
Joined
Mar 23, 2025
Points
263
Apr 27, 2025
#76
YesterdaysHero73 said:
Appreciate your "input" lol

Yes I'm growing in natural soil, 2" of my own closed loop copost mixed in. That's it. No inputs other then creek water:)
Click to expand...
Have you checked your own "special compost" mix to see if its at the correct pH for soil grows? This is probably the most overlooked area of home made mixes. The grower doesn't check and assumes that the mix is automatically of the correct pH. Before you get too far in, either check it yourself with a soil pH probe or take a sample to your local Agriculture office and have the soil tested.

If it's already where it should be, you have that peace of mind. If not, you will have more options for adjusting the pH without plants in it yet.
 
Reactions: YesterdaysHero73
Quote Reply

YesterdaysHero73

Posts
37
Reactions
31
Joined
Feb 17, 2025
Points
18
Apr 27, 2025
#77
ATLien415 said:
Astute point, I agree. The plants would certainly grow if we vanished. They would flourish. The only thing is that they would grow and flourish in a much different way than we use the plant. You would see re-naturalizing occur, the vast majority of cultivars go extinct, the prioritization of lanky growth and low-moisture pollen and intersex sites and more. It would basically be everything we love about the plant but in reverse. The plant as we know it is by definition intertwined with it's stewardship and alterations by humans.

My point is that doing a living soil web can be really tricky at scale. Organic apple farms have largely succumbed to using non-organic foliar sprays (practically required to be profitable in the industry). Depending on your crop, running a 1200 or 280000 acre site might mean that you're regularly applying rock for phosphorous - that is a slow process. Unless you started before we started farming, you're likely going to need a one or two time synthetic application. Water sources may entirely preclude certain micros based on water metrics, requiring intervention with presumed synthetics or remediating the water source. Potassium is another that is driven hard in some crops and can be tricky to give back at scale. The entire point of going closed-loop is to be able to scale, right? If it isn't scalable then it is pointless for the end goal of being better stewards for our planet.

I make the argument that the majority of micros (unless you're doing something truly closed loop like mostly using self-derived-ferments or farm animal compost for inputs) should be synthetic for folks. Bo, Mo, Co and such are tricky for organic inputs! Basically all micros are tricky unless you have a living animal's feces (after feeding it a plethora of inputs) or synthetics or centuries to wait. I think this is one of the arguments for ferments. I know the folks at Grease have shown some truly wild stuff with the humic/fulvics. Basically, if you give the plant a partially formed terpene or flavorant or cannabinoid or a derivative product, the plant is able to discern this and will take the path of least energy to form it's own (aka takes the building blocks up). Between that and the entire fact that many of the humic/fulvics can actually be home to microbial life as well, ferments are definitely the future (no matter what name or method they end up being associated with).

Another really good point that I never really thought of. Being how easy free salt transport is across root tissue, the reverse is also going to be true when it comes to decomposition. Mind gears are moving. :D I love what you're doing. Can't wait for the pics.
Click to expand...
Ill see of i can get some pics of my soil projects in a lil bit, stoked you get what I'm doing! It can confuse people round these parts.
 
Quote Reply

YesterdaysHero73

Posts
37
Reactions
31
Joined
Feb 17, 2025
Points
18
Apr 27, 2025
#78
Thanks for the advice!
 
Quote Reply
Page 4 of 4 · Replies 61–78 of 78
Prev
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
First Prev 4 of 4

Thread info

Replies 77
Views 7,276
Started Feb 17, 2025
Latest post Apr 27, 2025
Starter YesterdaysHero73
Forum Introduce Yourself

Latest posts

  • 2026 Outdoor Grows! let's see em!
    • Latest: durbin92810
    • 15 minutes ago
    General Outdoor Growing
  • I’m Week 4 into Flowering
    • Latest: April14th2014
    • Today at 3:15 AM
    General Indoor Growing
  • S
    Second grow - trying hydro in coco.
    • Latest: spase
    • Today at 2:59 AM
    Grow Diaries
  • Eternal Sun 2026 outdoor garden grow
    • Latest: Beazy
    • Today at 12:30 AM
    General Outdoor Growing
  • 40 days into cure , no change in smell or flavor
    • Latest: logic
    • Yesterday at 11:38 PM
    Cannabis Infirmary
  • Home
  • Forums
  • Site Happenings
  • Introduce Yourself
  • Hello, quest to grow with no inputs
  • Contact us
  • Terms and rules
  • Privacy policy
  • Help
  • Home
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2026 XenForo Ltd.
Menu
Log in

Sign up

  • Home
  • News
  • Classifieds
  • Forums
    • What's new Featured content New posts New Articles New articles New products Latest activity
  • Social
  • Strains
  • Live
  • Learn
  • Brands
X

Privacy & Transparency

We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

  • Personalized ads and content
  • Content measurement and audience insights

Do you accept cookies and these technologies?

X

Privacy & Transparency

We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

  • Personalized ads and content
  • Content measurement and audience insights

Do you accept cookies and these technologies?