• Home
  • Forums
  • Medical Cannabis Cultivation
  • General Indoor Growing
  • Organic Soil
  • Too much oster and crab shell ?!

Too much oster and crab shell ?!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Growjay
  • Start date Start date Apr 26, 2019
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Too much oster and crab shell ?!

Growjay Apr 26, 2019 20 Replies 10,885 Views
Page 1 of 2 · Replies 1–20 of 21
  • 1
  • 2
Next
1 of 2 Next Last
G

Growjay

Posts
6
Reactions
2
Joined
Apr 26, 2019
Points
3
Apr 26, 2019
#1
Hello all !!! I'm new to this forrum but have been searching for answers with no luck. I had a helper who claimed he knew what he was doing helping me ammend my soil. He added a whole box of crab meal 5lbs and a whole box of crushed oster shell 5lbs. Well I questioned him and he said trust him .......... well I'm about 2 weeks into veg and the girls seem to be growing very slow compared to using synthetics. Anyways ph is at 7.2 my dechlorinated tap water reads 5.8 so I have been watering with great white, later encorporate the molasses. . Just watering with 5.8 de Chlor water will bring my ph levels right ? My question is will my oh levels normalize and go down or is my soil ruined by too much ca. What can I do to fix this . ?
 
Last edited: Apr 26, 2019
Quote Reply
G

Growjay

Posts
6
Reactions
2
Joined
Apr 26, 2019
Points
3
Apr 26, 2019
#2
Had 8 cubic feet of soil 2 bags of perlite 50lbs of worm castings. Neem seed meal bat guano fish bone meal a little blood meal and kelp meal.
 
Quote Reply

oldskol4evr

Posts
12,306
Reactions
36,504
Joined
Oct 18, 2015
Points
438
Apr 26, 2019
#3
first off did you let the soil cook?
the crab meal is chiton,good stuff along with that is oyster shell flour calcium good stuff,both combined is some bad days for bugs,it cut them to pieces
next you have soil you didnt say what it was,all you added is really good stuff on amends,your buddy has the right idea by the way
next your 2 weeks in veg why are you feeding the plant anything at all,if hungry water only there food is in the soil ,the slow growth is the plant trying to find bottom of plant,the great white should have been added as a inoculant to the seed when you planted,i might be wrong but isnt it mychoriza? why use it?,if anything at all stands out to me is the nitrogen you have stormed your pot with,just my opinion.
your buddy has fixed the soil with major game players to combat insects and plenty of calcium for tender days of finishing the plant,neem crab oyster all cutters for larvae and such ,the neem cake is providing nitrogen too,so dont bust a bubble yet ,as he said trust him
so that is out the way,i say dont do anything but water the plant for first month,keep humidity high,temp around 80 and let them girls veg.
last off and most important of all,DID YOU COOK THE SOIL FOR AT LEAST A MONTH?
hahahahhah you will be alright partner just have patience and it work its way out,i strongly believe your friend has your best interest to heart
 
Reactions: Nightstick008, cpurola, Growjay and 2 others
Quote Reply

Aqua Man

Posts
26,479
Reactions
59,693
Joined
Jun 12, 2018
Points
638
Apr 26, 2019
#4
It takes a while for microbes in the soil to break down organic ferts and establish a decent colony if not set up to do so in the beginning . Synthetic nutrients are far more available to the plant until the soil builds up enough microbes. I'm guessing its just a waiting game at this point.
 
Reactions: cpurola and Growjay
Quote Reply

Beachwalker

Posts
7,055
Reactions
14,445
Joined
Apr 10, 2019
Points
313
Apr 26, 2019
#5
Growjay said:
Hello all !!! I'm new to this forrum but have been searching for answers with no luck. I had a helper who claimed he knew what he was doing helping me ammend my soil. He added a whole box of crab meal 5lbs and a whole box of crushed oster shell 5lbs. Well I questioned him and he said trust him .......... well I'm about 2 weeks into veg and the girls seem to be growing very slow compared to using synthetics. Anyways ph is at 7.2 my dechlorinated tap water reads 5.8 so I have been watering with great white, later encorporate the molasses. . Just watering with 5.8 de Chlor water will bring my ph levels right ? My question is will my oh levels normalize and go down or is my soil ruined by too much ca. What can I do to fix this . ?
Click to expand...
The pH of tap water is usually above 7 so I'm curious how you're getting 5.8? Have you checked your meter recently or whatever you're using to test?
 
Reactions: Growjay
Quote Reply
G

Growjay

Posts
6
Reactions
2
Joined
Apr 26, 2019
Points
3
Apr 26, 2019
#6
oldskol4evr said:
first off did you let the soil cook?
the crab meal is chiton,good stuff along with that is oyster shell flour calcium good stuff,both combined is some bad days for bugs,it cut them to pieces
next you have soil you didnt say what it was,all you added is really good stuff on amends,your buddy has the right idea by the way
next your 2 weeks in veg why are you feeding the plant anything at all,if hungry water only there food is in the soil ,the slow growth is the plant trying to find bottom of plant,the great white should have been added as a inoculant to the seed when you planted,i might be wrong but isnt it mychoriza? why use it?,if anything at all stands out to me is the nitrogen you have stormed your pot with,just my opinion.
your buddy has fixed the soil with major game players to combat insects and plenty of calcium for tender days of finishing the plant,neem crab oyster all cutters for larvae and such ,the neem cake is providing nitrogen too,so dont bust a bubble yet ,as he said trust him
so that is out the way,i say dont do anything but water the plant for first month,keep humidity high,temp around 80 and let them girls veg.
last off and most important of all,DID YOU COOK THE SOIL FOR AT LEAST A MONTH?
hahahahhah you will be alright partner just have patience and it work its way out,i strongly believe your friend has your best interest to heart
Click to expand...
sorry gentleman for the late reply . Ok I was told if I dont use tons of bone meal and blood meal that it wont cook and that "u don't need it to cook " there's plenty of available from all the goodies and that the microbes will eat and replenish more down the road. That's the whole reason I'm questioning everything now cause from reading it all points too a different method. I did sprinkle great white in the soil which was mg natures organic ( never used it before but everything else was bought up around me ) I know it's not the greatest so stuffed it with perlite for aeration. The soil sat in plastic barrels with lids for 3 weeks but never got hot ...
A few pics of the plants and I wish I could shake your hand for your time.
 

Attachments

  • 20190426_212933.jpg
    194.7 KB · Views: 1,305
  • 20190426_212922.jpg
    143.4 KB · Views: 1,149
  • 20190426_212949.jpg
    171.2 KB · Views: 1,092
  • 20190426_212943.jpg
    202.5 KB · Views: 1,133
Quote Reply
G

Growjay

Posts
6
Reactions
2
Joined
Apr 26, 2019
Points
3
Apr 26, 2019
#7
Beachwalker said:
The pH of tap water is usually above 7 so I'm curious how you're getting 5.8? Have you checked your meter recently or whatever you're using to test?
Click to expand...
You were 100% right I rechecked using a brand new bluelab meter which I have never used before and didnt let it sit all the way. It shot up to 7.2 when I swirled it and let the prob sit in the cup. Thank you sir
 
Reactions: Beachwalker
Quote Reply
G

Growjay

Posts
6
Reactions
2
Joined
Apr 26, 2019
Points
3
Apr 26, 2019
#8
I also planted a cover crop of a mix of clover and a few other select seeds and I put a half pound of insect frass and 50 lbs of worm castings feather meal alfalfa and rock phosphate. Sorry for the lack of all the info. Those all were added in moderation.
 
Last edited: Apr 26, 2019
Quote Reply

Winter323

Posts
77
Reactions
75
Joined
Feb 14, 2019
Points
18
May 7, 2019
#9
Most experienced organic dudes look down on using perlite, as it kinda screws over the top of the soil where you want to have your cover crops, beneficial insects, mulch layer and the like. Really those are both slow release calcium so shouldnt be too much of a problem, but that is not to say that your soil mix wont have other problems. But just keep an eye on things and trying to go aggressive on low ppm foliars, focussing on kelp (rhizotonic) + worm castings, cal/mag and full spectrum nutes. If you keep at it with a good mulch layer, bugs, worms and the like your soil should be getting better each cycle. For future mixes look at going heavy on the rock dust, check out the mountainorganics website and instagram for help.
 
Reactions: TimK
Quote Reply
T

TimK

Posts
25
Reactions
44
Joined
Sep 13, 2025
Points
18
Oct 4, 2025
#10
Winter323 said:
Most experienced organic dudes look down on using perlite, as it kinda screws over the top of the soil where you want to have your cover crops, beneficial insects, mulch layer and the like. Really those are both slow release calcium so shouldnt be too much of a problem, but that is not to say that your soil mix wont have other problems. But just keep an eye on things and trying to go aggressive on low ppm foliars, focussing on kelp (rhizotonic) + worm castings, cal/mag and full spectrum nutes. If you keep at it with a good mulch layer, bugs, worms and the like your soil should be getting better each cycle. For future mixes look at going heavy on the rock dust, check out the mountainorganics website and instagram for help.
Click to expand...
I know that this is a very old thread- but use Rice Hulls as an alternative to Perlite!!!
 
Reactions: Oldchucky
Quote Reply

Oldchucky

Supporter
Posts
14,773
Reactions
50,177
Joined
May 4, 2021
Points
438
Oct 4, 2025
#11
TimK said:
I know that this is a very old thread- but use Rice Hulls as an alternative to Perlite!!!
Click to expand...
In my opinion perlite is the second most underused amendment! Been using the same soil for four years and it’s got a ton of Perlite in it! My roots breathe like nobody’s business!
 
Reactions: TimK
Quote Reply
T

TimK

Posts
25
Reactions
44
Joined
Sep 13, 2025
Points
18
Oct 4, 2025
#12
Oldchucky said:
In my opinion perlite is the second most underused amendment! Been using the same soil for four years and it’s got a ton of Perlite in it! My roots breathe like nobody’s business!
Click to expand...
Mine too- but have you tried or even heard of Rice Hulls?
Look it up- in my other forum app (420), people were talking about it and I investigated/bought some.
Cheap as, natural alternative to Perlite that gives nutrients as it breaks down & best of all it keeps fungus gnats at bay when used as a thin mulch!
Then there's also Wollastonite, a cheap alternative to lime...
Trust me, you can't go wrong with a bag like this for under $10-
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20250913_154546_Chrome.jpg
    93.2 KB · Views: 1
Reactions: Oldchucky
Quote Reply
T

TimK

Posts
25
Reactions
44
Joined
Sep 13, 2025
Points
18
Oct 4, 2025
#13
Oldchucky said:
In my opinion perlite is the second most underused amendment! Been using the same soil for four years and it’s got a ton of Perlite in it! My roots breathe like nobody’s business!
Click to expand...
By the way- I was talking to a grower the other day and apparently he has a great watering technique to get the roots poking through the 5 gallon fabric pots-
Dunk them for 10 minutes, once a week and let them drip dry- then chuck them back in the tent...
 
Reactions: Oldchucky
Quote Reply

Oldchucky

Supporter
Posts
14,773
Reactions
50,177
Joined
May 4, 2021
Points
438
Oct 4, 2025
#14
TimK said:
Mine too- but have you tried or even heard of Rice Hulls?
Look it up- in my other forum app (420), people were talking about it and I investigated/bought some.
Cheap as, natural alternative to Perlite that gives nutrients as it breaks down & best of all it keeps fungus gnats at bay when used as a thin mulch!
Then there's also Wollastonite, a cheap alternative to lime...
Trust me, you can't go wrong with a bag like this for under $10-
Click to expand...
Oh yeah! I’ve seen it and heard of it! Looks like a good amendment! But it would be too expensive for me! And I would have to replace it every year due to breakdown! How many bags of that would I need for 9 35 gallon pots? I can get 4 ft.³ of per light for less than 25! just messing with you a little! Yeah, I’ve heard it’s great stuff! Just not for all applications!
 
Last edited: Oct 4, 2025
Reactions: TimK
Quote Reply

orggrwr

Posts
876
Reactions
3,136
Joined
Feb 20, 2024
Points
243
Oct 4, 2025
#15
I got this bag on Amazon a while back. It's a 45lb bag and I believe i paid around 50 to 60 bucks for it. It's enough to last me at least a year and I use a lot of rice hulls.
 

Attachments

  • 20251004_204245.jpg
    112.9 KB · Views: 2
  • 20251004_204152.jpg
    146.2 KB · Views: 2
  • 20251004_204126.jpg
    182.8 KB · Views: 1
Reactions: Oldchucky and TimK
Quote Reply
T

TimK

Posts
25
Reactions
44
Joined
Sep 13, 2025
Points
18
Oct 4, 2025
#16
Oldchucky said:
Oh yeah! I’ve seen it and heard of it! Looks like a good amendment! But it would be too expensive for me! And I would have to replace it every year due to breakdown! How many bags of that would I need for 9 35 gallon pots? I can get 4 ft.³ of per light for less than 25! just messing with you a little! Yeah, I’ve heard it’s great stuff! Just not for all applications!
Click to expand...
Cheers mate- glad it didn't fall on dead ears, means a lot
Qoute- "Rice hulls improve cannabis soil by enhancing aeration, drainage, and water retention, providing slow-release silica and nitrogen, and acting as a mulch to reduce fungus gnats and maintain soil moisture. They can serve as a sustainable alternative to perlite and vermiculite, contributing organic matter and promoting microbial life in the soil".

Perfect for those whom don't get Silica from soil & I especially like the moisture retention/beneficial microbes...

*Oi!!
9 x 35 Gallon pots!?
What the hell are you up to!
Love to see the setup- here's another tip that might really make you think I'm nutters! Ex gfriend old man's mates and he had a particular strain that they'd share/grow exclusively & his booster was a small handful of ANFO over ten or so plants..
I don't know whether it was that, the strain or both- but these plants (outside) had the hugest heads!
That real pale green, thick textured leaves with bright orange pistils...
 
Quote Reply
T

TimK

Posts
25
Reactions
44
Joined
Sep 13, 2025
Points
18
Oct 4, 2025
#17
orggrwr said:
I got this bag on Amazon a while back. It's a 45lb bag and I believe i paid around 50 to 60 bucks for it. It's enough to last me at least a year and I use a lot of rice hulls.
Click to expand...
Really?
Fantastic to hear!
45kg is beautiful value- how long ago was this? I'm not in need of that much, nor do I think that I have the room but it's worth checking meanwhile...
 
Quote Reply

Oldchucky

Supporter
Posts
14,773
Reactions
50,177
Joined
May 4, 2021
Points
438
Oct 5, 2025
#18
TimK said:
Cheers mate- glad it didn't fall on dead ears, means a lot
Qoute- "Rice hulls improve cannabis soil by enhancing aeration, drainage, and water retention, providing slow-release silica and nitrogen, and acting as a mulch to reduce fungus gnats and maintain soil moisture. They can serve as a sustainable alternative to perlite and vermiculite, contributing organic matter and promoting microbial life in the soil".

Perfect for those whom don't get Silica from soil & I especially like the moisture retention/beneficial microbes...

*Oi!!
9 x 35 Gallon pots!?
What the hell are you up to!
Love to see the setup- here's another tip that might really make you think I'm nutters! Ex gfriend old man's mates and he had a particular strain that they'd share/grow exclusively & his booster was a small handful of ANFO over ten or so plants..
I don't know whether it was that, the strain or both- but these plants (outside) had the hugest heads!
That real pale green, thick textured leaves with bright orange pistils...
Click to expand...
Here you go, Tim.
 
Reactions: Leste, Greenadian and TimK
Quote Reply
T

TimK

Posts
25
Reactions
44
Joined
Sep 13, 2025
Points
18
Oct 5, 2025
#19
Oldchucky said:
Here you go, Tim.View attachment 2539764View attachment 2539765
Click to expand...
Bloody beautiful thing, that is..
I see you've wisely got them fenced off- Roo's?
Crikey, healthy looking buggers! Nice topping as well.
Nice heads too- what strain?
 
Reactions: Leste
Quote Reply
T

TimK

Posts
25
Reactions
44
Joined
Sep 13, 2025
Points
18
Oct 5, 2025
#20
Oldchucky said:
Here you go, Tim.View attachment 2539764View attachment 2539765
Click to expand...
Damn, can't get this picture off of my mind, now!
I'm more of a litres guy and I had to check my converter:
45 gallons is, 170.344 Litres!

Near on a ⅕ of a tonne, above ground, aerated growing medium for each plant- even more impressive..
 
Reactions: Greenadian
Quote Reply
Page 1 of 2 · Replies 1–20 of 21
  • 1
  • 2
Next
1 of 2 Next Last

Thread info

Replies 20
Views 10,885
Started Apr 26, 2019
Latest post Oct 5, 2025
Starter Growjay
Forum Organic Soil

Latest posts

  • Eternal Sun 2026 outdoor garden grow
    • Latest: Leste
    • 2 minutes ago
    General Outdoor Growing
  • R
    So, you're new here, eh? Here's some stuff you may find handy...
    • Latest: Ralphbk86
    • 3 minutes ago
    Introduce Yourself
  • 2026 Outdoor Grows! let's see em!
    • Latest: FarmerScotty
    • 48 minutes ago
    General Outdoor Growing
  • B
    What do you make of these purple marks on my seedlings
    • Latest: Barraka
    • 57 minutes ago
    General Indoor Growing
  • Cpurola's Outdoor grow in Southeast Michigan 2026
    • Latest: cpurola
    • Today at 7:08 AM
    General Outdoor Growing
  • Home
  • Forums
  • Medical Cannabis Cultivation
  • General Indoor Growing
  • Organic Soil
  • Too much oster and crab shell ?!
  • Contact us
  • Terms and rules
  • Privacy policy
  • Help
  • Home
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2026 XenForo Ltd.
Menu
Log in

Sign up

  • Home
  • News
  • Classifieds
  • Forums
    • What's new Featured content New posts New Articles New articles New products Latest activity
  • Social
  • Strains
  • Live
  • Learn
  • Brands
X

Privacy & Transparency

We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

  • Personalized ads and content
  • Content measurement and audience insights

Do you accept cookies and these technologies?

X

Privacy & Transparency

We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

  • Personalized ads and content
  • Content measurement and audience insights

Do you accept cookies and these technologies?