• Home
  • Forums
  • Medical Cannabis Cultivation
  • General Indoor Growing
  • Hydroponics
  • First grow. Hydro or soil?

First grow. Hydro or soil?

  • Thread starter Thread starter caliclouds
  • Start date Start date Dec 10, 2024
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

First grow. Hydro or soil?

caliclouds Dec 10, 2024 14 Replies 2,207 Views
Page 1 of 1 · Replies 1–15 of 15
1
C

caliclouds

Posts
2
Reactions
6
Joined
Dec 10, 2024
Points
3
Dec 10, 2024
#1
How's things guys, i want to start my first grow. I dont have any experience i am a complete beginner. Ive done some research and im thinking of going with a dwc hydro system. Im thinking of going for a 48×48×80" tent and feminised seeds. Is a 200w LED enough or should i go stronger. Any tips/advice and any estimated yields? Thanks in advance to anyone that helps!
 
Reactions: Florida_Mike and BB22
Quote Reply

BB22

Posts
3,846
Reactions
15,992
Joined
Jan 17, 2023
Points
263
Dec 10, 2024
#2
My .02, go soil ! Never worry about PH
 
Reactions: Cophiljay and Florida_Mike
Quote Reply
C

caliclouds

Posts
2
Reactions
6
Joined
Dec 10, 2024
Points
3
Dec 10, 2024
#3
BB22 said:
My .02, go soil ! Never worry about PH
Click to expand...
Appreciate the reply, i would prefer hydroponic because from what ive read its faster and bigger grows
 
Reactions: amneziaHaze, DillyTrying2Learn and BB22
Quote Reply

Justlovetogrow

Posts
3,785
Reactions
15,401
Joined
Jan 8, 2021
Points
263
Dec 10, 2024
#4
caliclouds said:
Appreciate the reply, i would prefer hydroponic because from what ive read its faster and bigger grows
Click to expand...
Then maybe use coco then sort of a happy medium between DWC and soil still classified as hydro hard to overwater explosive growth dwc for a brand new grower is like giving someone on their l plates keys to an f1
 
Reactions: firstgrowdontknow and Florida_Mike
Quote Reply

BB22

Posts
3,846
Reactions
15,992
Joined
Jan 17, 2023
Points
263
Dec 10, 2024
#5
caliclouds said:
Appreciate the reply, i would prefer hydroponic because from what ive read its faster and bigger grows
Click to expand...

Have not tried hydro. Still learning to be honest. I’m trying make perpetual grow as esy as can be . High yield would be great ! not in a crazy rush for a bounty
 
Reactions: Florida_Mike
Quote Reply
D

DillyTrying2Learn

Posts
228
Reactions
247
Joined
Jun 20, 2024
Points
43
Dec 10, 2024
#6
Hydro is clean and can be challenging but it has insane growth rates. I have a 5x5 tent with 4 site RDWC and I have a 1000W light in there's it's not about the power but about the coverage.
 
Reactions: Florida_Mike
Quote Reply

amneziaHaze

Posts
2,604
Reactions
4,913
Joined
Sep 21, 2024
Points
263
Dec 11, 2024
#7
If you want to ignore the plant for a week go soil.if you want to work on it every day go hydro.hydro means calculating and using meters.

Hydro will give more flower.and since its allways wet faster growth.you could have same growth in soil but nobody keeps it petfectly wet 24/7
 
Reactions: HerbalEdu and Florida_Mike
Quote Reply

Florida_Mike

Supporter
At the edge of the map, blowing kisses at dragons.
Posts
4,355
Reactions
19,489
Joined
Nov 26, 2024
Points
263
Dec 11, 2024
#8
agree with above, you should learn to walk before you try running a 25 mile marathon. as my signature suggests

you must walk down many roads (funny how much it applies to growing weed). b4 you really hit your stride and find

what really works for & suits you.

good luck, happy growing & welcome to the fam!
 
Quote Reply
D

DillyTrying2Learn

Posts
228
Reactions
247
Joined
Jun 20, 2024
Points
43
Dec 11, 2024
#9
If you want to do hydro, do it. Don't listen to all these dirty growers. I jumped into hydro head first to learn to grow and don't wish for a second I went dirt. Also, you do not have to mess with your plants every day with hydro, if you chose to you can. In fact with hydro, the right feed and a large enough resivor you can go much much longer than dirt without tending to your plants. If you want to do hydro, do it. You also won't have gnats and other bugs in your house hatching out of your soil.
 
Reactions: Olddude420 and Florida_Mike
Quote Reply

amneziaHaze

Posts
2,604
Reactions
4,913
Joined
Sep 21, 2024
Points
263
Dec 11, 2024
#10
DillyTrying2Learn said:
If you want to do hydro, do it. Don't listen to all these dirty growers. I jumped into hydro head first to learn to grow and don't wish for a second I went dirt. Also, you do not have to mess with your plants every day with hydro, if you chose to you can. In fact with hydro, the right feed and a large enough resivor you can go much much longer than dirt without tending to your plants. If you want to do hydro, do it. You also won't have gnats and other bugs in your house hatching out of your soil.
Click to expand...
Large reservoar slow changes.hard to find that sweetspot.you put 100ppm too much in 7 days that will burn the plant. I have 10L and 70L both cant be left alone in flower for a week. 10L drinks all its water in 2.5days

But he is correct you dont need to learn soil to start dwc.one has nothing to do with the other.2 different worlds
 
Reactions: Florida_Mike
Quote Reply
D

DillyTrying2Learn

Posts
228
Reactions
247
Joined
Jun 20, 2024
Points
43
Dec 11, 2024
#11
amneziaHaze said:
Large reservoar slow changes.hard to find that sweetspot.you put 100ppm too much in 7 days that will burn the plant. I have 10L and 70L both cant be left alone in flower for a week. 10L drinks all its water in 2.5days

But he is correct you dont need to learn soil to start dwc.one has nothing to do with the other.2 different worlds
Click to expand...
My system holds up to 46 gallons and if I chose to I can leave it for a week at a time. I went to Maui for 2 weeksand just had my dad come by and top off one time and everything was fine. Water was a little low but the plants looked happy as can be. I think the same thing can happen with dirt too though, if have you a feed that is to strong and water and leave for a week and you'll fry your plants, except you can't just dump the water and start over. Or you can deal with over watering/under watering problems which don't exist in hydro. You just have to not drown them lol.
 
Reactions: Florida_Mike
Quote Reply

Florida_Mike

Supporter
At the edge of the map, blowing kisses at dragons.
Posts
4,355
Reactions
19,489
Joined
Nov 26, 2024
Points
263
Dec 11, 2024
#12
DillyTrying2Learn said:
My system holds up to 46 gallons and if I chose to I can leave it for a week at a time. I went to Maui for 2 weeksand just had my dad come by and top off one time and everything was fine. Water was a little low but the plants looked happy as can be. I think the same thing can happen with dirt too though, if have you a feed that is to strong and water and leave for a week and you'll fry your plants, except you can't just dump the water and start over. Or you can deal with over watering/under watering problems which don't exist in hydro. You just have to not drown them lol.
Click to expand...
hey man, you've got this shit down! i need to pick ur brain some and see how your sump (?) system works. in my 4x8 (w/ rockwool uni-slabs) i'll only have a 20gal reservoir, and i know 10 plants will easily drink 10 gallons per day. i may have to re-think things & go with a smaller plant count or something. this is all an experiment to me to see if i still got what it takes.
thanks for posting -peace-
 
Quote Reply
D

DillyTrying2Learn

Posts
228
Reactions
247
Joined
Jun 20, 2024
Points
43
Dec 11, 2024
#13
FloridaMike said:
hey man, you've got this shit down! i need to pick ur brain some and see how your sump (?) system works. in my 4x8 (w/ rockwool uni-slabs) i'll only have a 20gal reservoir, and i know 10 plants will easily drink 10 gallons per day. i may have to re-think things & go with a smaller plant count or something. this is all an experiment to me to see if i still got what it takes.
thanks for posting -peace-
Click to expand...
I have 4 plants in a PA Fallponics RDWC set up with the 13gal resivors. One thing about hydro is it is definitely much more expensive to get started.
 
Reactions: Olddude420 and Florida_Mike
Quote Reply

Florida_Mike

Supporter
At the edge of the map, blowing kisses at dragons.
Posts
4,355
Reactions
19,489
Joined
Nov 26, 2024
Points
263
Dec 11, 2024
#14
DillyTrying2Learn said:
I have 4 plants in a PA Fallponics RDWC set up with the 13gal resivors. One thing about hydro is it is definitely much more expensive to get started.
Click to expand...
absolutely more expensive, but the pay off is oh soooooo worth it. i could teach my method to almost anyone within a week (that's what my training consisted of once i got lucky and found the right mentor, after many not very good results of trying to go it alone) it's actually quite simple if one follows a few simple rules and recipes...
-peace out brother & thanks for the posts & encouragement you give to others
 
Quote Reply

Olddude420

Posts
286
Reactions
582
Joined
Aug 5, 2024
Points
93
Mar 4, 2025
#15
DillyTrying2Learn said:
If you want to do hydro, do it. Don't listen to all these dirty growers. I jumped into hydro head first to learn to grow and don't wish for a second I went dirt. Also, you do not have to mess with your plants every day with hydro, if you chose to you can. In fact with hydro, the right feed and a large enough resivor you can go much much longer than dirt without tending to your plants. If you want to do hydro, do it. You also won't have gnats and other bugs in your house hatching out of your soil.
Click to expand...
I agree with this. Want to do hydro, do it. I did last year & loved it. More expensive but well worth it. Just kicked off my next grow a month ago. Flipped to 12/12 today.
DillyTrying2Learn said:
I have 4 plants in a PA Fallponics RDWC set up with the 13gal resivors. One thing about hydro is it is definitely much more expensive to get started.t
Click to expand...
Agreed. I have same setup & love it.
 
Quote Reply
Page 1 of 1 · Replies 1–15 of 15
1

Thread info

Replies 14
Views 2,207
Started Dec 10, 2024
Latest post Mar 4, 2025
Starter caliclouds
Forum Hydroponics

Latest posts

  • S
    Any tips for my first guerilla grow?
    • Latest: SenshiGrows
    • 13 minutes ago
    General Outdoor Growing
  • 2026 Outdoor Grows! let's see em!
    • Latest: grayoldnproud
    • 57 minutes ago
    General Outdoor Growing
  • N
    Auto Flowers Odd growth Help
    • Latest: Nalali
    • 58 minutes ago
    Cannabis Infirmary
  • Blueberry Muffin by Humboldt Seeds
    • Latest: Gmix
    • Today at 7:18 AM
    Grow Diaries
  • I’m Week 4 into Flowering
    • Latest: Gmix
    • Today at 7:10 AM
    General Indoor Growing
  • Home
  • Forums
  • Medical Cannabis Cultivation
  • General Indoor Growing
  • Hydroponics
  • First grow. Hydro or soil?
  • Contact us
  • Terms and rules
  • Privacy policy
  • Help
  • Home
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2026 XenForo Ltd.
Menu
Log in

Sign up

  • Home
  • News
  • Classifieds
  • Forums
    • What's new Featured content New posts New Articles New articles New products Latest activity
  • Social
  • Strains
  • Live
  • Learn
  • Brands
X

Privacy & Transparency

We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

  • Personalized ads and content
  • Content measurement and audience insights

Do you accept cookies and these technologies?

X

Privacy & Transparency

We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

  • Personalized ads and content
  • Content measurement and audience insights

Do you accept cookies and these technologies?