• Home
  • Forums
  • Medical Cannabis Cultivation
  • General Indoor Growing
  • Hid Vs Led - Best Thing I Have Ever Seen

Hid Vs Led - Best Thing I Have Ever Seen

  • Thread starter Thread starter OldManRiver
  • Start date Start date Jan 8, 2019
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Hid Vs Led - Best Thing I Have Ever Seen

OldManRiver Jan 8, 2019 87 Replies 18,076 Views
Page 2 of 5 · Replies 21–40 of 88
Prev
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Next
First Prev 2 of 5 Next Last

OldManRiver

Posts
1,390
Reactions
2,880
Joined
Jul 20, 2017
Points
263
Jan 17, 2019
#21
Mytwhyt said:
Don't abandon the 315 watt cmh/lec just yet.. I got 26 oz from 2 SS315 watt cmh and 2 waterfarms.. That's just 6 oz short of 2 lbs.. 5 wks veg, 10 weeks flower after 12/12 flip..
300 watts of good/better led should be able to do a lb in a reasonable amount of time.. By reasonable, i mean in about 120 days from sprout..
Click to expand...
excellent yield per watt.

I liked the discussion in the video about tradeoffs between yield and potency, in considering spectrums that are more red vs slightly more blue oriented. I live in a legal state; I only grow for consumption. I'm running 3000K quantums, and adding UVB as a result of seeing this.
 
Reactions: UncleRomulus, Freshone and Mr.jiujitsu
Quote Reply

OldManRiver

Posts
1,390
Reactions
2,880
Joined
Jul 20, 2017
Points
263
Jan 17, 2019
#22
And the discussion of increasing light height improving lower bud production was eye opening.
 
Reactions: UncleRomulus and Freshone
Quote Reply

Freshone

Posts
1,620
Reactions
6,140
Joined
Jul 6, 2016
Points
263
Jan 17, 2019
#23
3 balls said:
I get what you're saying but when I think out the math on switching over, it goes like this. Say I'm paying $50 per month per 1000W DE HPS now, IF I can get the same results from LED at 600W, 60% of $50 is still $30. If I take another 10% of for reduced AC costs, I'm down to $25 savings per month per light. I would love to save that but it would take 2 1/2 years to get that $800 savings. I don't know much about LED's other than they seem to improve the technology really fast and frequently (reminds me of Iphones), which is why I think long before my power savings cover the cost of switching, the light will be an outdated dinosaur.
Click to expand...
Like i said alot depends on your power rates,If i just ran 1 1000 hps (i dont,) the absolute cheapest it would cost me without AC or anything else is about 80-100 a month.I have a friend in another state with alot of hydro power that pays 11 cents a kwh with no tiers so he could give 2 fucks about efficiency,I on the other hand pay like 14 cents then it jumps to 25 cents and QUICKLY once again jumps to 45 cents( Cali Rates).I am in tier 1 (the lowest) on the 1st of the month for about an hour once my lights come on,lol.
 
Reactions: UncleRomulus, 3 balls and MidwestToker
Quote Reply

MidwestToker

Posts
1,228
Reactions
2,842
Joined
Feb 20, 2014
Points
263
Jan 17, 2019
#24
3 balls said:
If you're getting a lb out of 300W you are da man. If I was building a new room and had to buy new fixtures anyway, I would give LED a little more consideration.
Click to expand...
I'll put this out there again.
21 days of veg from rooted cuttings. 9 liter pots of coir dtw. 200 watts of 3k Samsung strips, 70 watts of supplemental diodes. 18 dried ounces.
 
Reactions: OldManRiver, Madmax, Dan789 and 5 others
Quote Reply

MidwestToker

Posts
1,228
Reactions
2,842
Joined
Feb 20, 2014
Points
263
Jan 17, 2019
#25
Freshone said:
Like i said alot depends on your power rates,If i just ran 1 1000 hps (i dont,) the absolute cheapest it would cost me without AC or anything else is about 80-100 a month.I have a friend in another state with alot of hydro power that pays 11 cents a kwh with no tiers so he could give 2 fucks about efficiency,I on the other hand pay like 14 cents then it jumps to 25 cents and QUICKLY once again jumps to 45 cents( Cali Rates).I am in tier 1 (the lowest) on the 1st of the month for about an hour once my lights come on,lol.
Click to expand...
10 cents a KWH where I am at and I'm still switching over to LED's.
 
Reactions: Dan789 and Freshone
Quote Reply

OldManRiver

Posts
1,390
Reactions
2,880
Joined
Jul 20, 2017
Points
263
Jan 17, 2019
#26
MidwestToker said:
10 cents a KWH where I am at and I'm still switching over to LED's.
Click to expand...
7.7 cents per kwh here, I'll still never own an HID lamp again. Low heat, quality light, low profile are all helpful.
 
Reactions: Freshone and MidwestToker
Quote Reply

3 balls

Posts
582
Reactions
1,058
Joined
Mar 18, 2018
Points
143
Jan 17, 2019
#27
Freshone said:
Like i said alot depends on your power rates,If i just ran 1 1000 hps (i dont,) the absolute cheapest it would cost me without AC or anything else is about 80-100 a month.I have a friend in another state with alot of hydro power that pays 11 cents a kwh with no tiers so he could give 2 fucks about efficiency,I on the other hand pay like 14 cents then it jumps to 25 cents and QUICKLY once again jumps to 45 cents( Cali Rates).I am in tier 1 (the lowest) on the 1st of the month for about an hour once my lights come on,lol.
Click to expand...
DAMN!!! I will never complain about my power bill again. I knew the national average was around .11 a kwh and Alaska, Hawaii and a few others could be double or triple, but those tiers are insane. Stands to reason there is a lot of LED fans by default. I on the other hand, paying .09 with no tiers can wait for this wave of LED R&D to level off. I have no doubt LED is the future but I'm old enough to remember a VCR costing $900.
 
Reactions: Dan789, UncleRomulus, Freshone and 1 other person
Quote Reply

Buzzer777

Posts
4,053
Reactions
10,388
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Points
263
Jan 17, 2019
#28
3 balls said:
DAMN!!! I will never complain about my power bill again. I knew the national average was around .11 a kwh and Alaska, Hawaii and a few others could be double or triple, but those tiers are insane. Stands to reason there is a lot of LED fans by default. I on the other hand, paying .09 with no tiers can wait for this wave of LED R&D to level off. I have no doubt LED is the future but I'm old enough to remember a VCR costing $900.
Click to expand...
Betamax! LMAO
 
Reactions: Dan789, crimsonecho, UncleRomulus and 2 others
Quote Reply

Freshone

Posts
1,620
Reactions
6,140
Joined
Jul 6, 2016
Points
263
Jan 17, 2019
#29
LMAO,If i had power the cost of you guys i would be like el chapo!



Tiered Rate Plan
 
Reactions: MidwestToker, Buzzer777, UncleRomulus and 1 other person
Quote Reply
F

FutureGrower

Posts
606
Reactions
927
Joined
Nov 19, 2017
Points
93
Jan 17, 2019
#30
I watched this video a few months ago. It really made me think it was a nexlight commercial if I remember correctly. Shango los has great stuff though
 
Reactions: Buzzer777 and UncleRomulus
Quote Reply

UncleRomulus

Posts
1,356
Reactions
4,415
Joined
Aug 9, 2018
Points
263
Jan 17, 2019
#31
I was going to just say that as well. I’ll take any 315 s anyone is selling cheap all day long. 300 watts of cobs wouldn’t even put a 315 to shame at all. I know led s are super efficient and I’m sold on em actually.. but folks do exaggerate. I was told 400 watts of led would replace a 1k hps.. ya no.. 600 maybe. Think about it this way. If one got 1 gpw off a 1k.. who’s claiming 2.5 gpw off 400 watts of cobs.. anyways what I’m getting at is there’s no need to exaggerate.. led s are sweet and all but they won’t breast feed you or anything geez haha
 
Reactions: Dan789, Galvatron, cemchris and 2 others
Quote Reply
F

FutureGrower

Posts
606
Reactions
927
Joined
Nov 19, 2017
Points
93
Jan 17, 2019
#32
UncleRomulus said:
I was going to just say that as well. I’ll take any 315 s anyone is selling cheap all day long. 300 watts of cobs wouldn’t even put a 315 to shame at all. I know led s are super efficient and I’m sold on em actually.. but folks do exaggerate. I was told 400 watts of led would replace a 1k hps.. ya no.. 600 maybe. Think about it this way. If one got 1 gpw off a 1k.. who’s claiming 2.5 gpw off 400 watts of cobs.. anyways what I’m getting at is there’s no need to exaggerate.. led s are sweet and all but they won’t breast feed you or anything geez haha
Click to expand...

I use LEDs but theres a huge variance in LED technology some of it really is "special" but I dont believe it's a night and day.

There is one massive difference, my 315cmh puts off more heat than my 600 watt led. So it will 100% save you cooling cost, some people just think they're magic or something lol.
 
Reactions: MidwestToker and UncleRomulus
Quote Reply

UncleRomulus

Posts
1,356
Reactions
4,415
Joined
Aug 9, 2018
Points
263
Jan 17, 2019
#33
FutureGrower said:
I use LEDs but theres a huge variance in LED technology some of it really is "special" but I dont believe it's a night and day.

There is one massive difference, my 315cmh puts off more heat than my 600 watt led. So it will 100% save you cooling cost, some people just think they're magic or something lol.
Click to expand...
Haha. It just depends. I need the heat in a big way or I’m spending watts warming up my led only chamber. Very different electricity cost and overal climate in Northern Canada vs Southern states for example. It’s currently minus 40 and I’m just struggling to keep my babies warm... under 1k hps.. haha. My poor led chamber.. had to throw my 150 hps in there for so damn heeeeat haha
 
Reactions: MidwestToker, Growster240, 3 balls and 1 other person
Quote Reply
F

FutureGrower

Posts
606
Reactions
927
Joined
Nov 19, 2017
Points
93
Jan 17, 2019
#34
UncleRomulus said:
Haha. It just depends. I need the heat in a big way or I’m spending watts warming up my led only chamber. Very different electricity cost and overal climate in Northern Canada vs Southern states for example. It’s currently minus 40 and I’m just struggling to keep my babies warm... under 1k hps.. haha. My poor led chamber.. had to throw my 150 hps in there for so damn heeeeat haha
Click to expand...

Haha I'm in oregon we have some mild winters compared to you guys!
 
Reactions: UncleRomulus
Quote Reply

Buzzer777

Posts
4,053
Reactions
10,388
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Points
263
Jan 18, 2019
#35
FutureGrower said:
I watched this video a few months ago. It really made me think it was a nexlight commercial if I remember correctly. Shango los has great stuff though
Click to expand...
One of my 1st good LED lights was/is a Nextlight Mini. It runs at a modest 150 watts from the wall, (and is augmented by another 350 LED watts in a 3x3) and seems well built but kinda pricey by some of today's standards. (ie: the HLG QBs etc). I sold off my cheaper Import burples a few ago, but always kept the Nextlight. Even though it's a dinosaur by today's standards....it grows pretty nice weed! (their big "MEGA" model is pretty damn nice for a 4x4!)
 
Reactions: FutureGrower
Quote Reply
F

FutureGrower

Posts
606
Reactions
927
Joined
Nov 19, 2017
Points
93
Jan 18, 2019
#36
Buzzer777 said:
One of my 1st good LED lights was/is a Nextlight Mini. It runs at a modest 150 watts from the wall, (and is augmented by another 350 LED watts in a 3x3) and seems well built but kinda pricey by some of today's standards. (ie: the HLG QBs etc). I sold off my cheaper Import burples a few ago, but always kept the Nextlight. Even though it's a dinosaur by today's standards....it grows pretty nice weed! (their big "MEGA" model is pretty damn nice for a 4x4!)
Click to expand...

They look badass too! No hate here I was just trying to bring a little balance. I think LED is the way forward, but just have to be very careful on which ones you buy.

That's cool you still have your old light in the lineup. They had some really cool veg lights that worked well for thin corridors. I suppose a lot of lights would be good too but it just fit the grow space so well (seen on a grow journal from a different forum)
 
Reactions: Buzzer777
Quote Reply

Buzzer777

Posts
4,053
Reactions
10,388
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Points
263
Jan 18, 2019
#37
FutureGrower said:
They look badass too! No hate here I was just trying to bring a little balance. I think LED is the way forward, but just have to be very careful on which ones you buy.

That's cool you still have your old light in the lineup. They had some really cool veg lights that worked well for thin corridors. I suppose a lot of lights would be good too but it just fit the grow space so well (seen on a grow journal from a different forum)
Click to expand...
I agree..That's why I chose all Samsung SMD boards for the past few purchases. I have a mix of QB132s (2700k and 3500k) and one of their older 288's in 3000k. I run a few Photon Sunboards with alternating 4000k and 2700k in veg (same 301B diodes). Also in the breeding tent..I have been trying a QB288v2, 301C KNOCKOFF board(s) with excellent results. (3000k, but 9" sq as opposed to the QB 288's rectangular footprint). I will keep that Nextlight Mini until it either weakens or is no longer viable!
 
Reactions: FutureGrower
Quote Reply
F

FutureGrower

Posts
606
Reactions
927
Joined
Nov 19, 2017
Points
93
Jan 18, 2019
#38
Buzzer777 said:
I agree..That's why I chose all Samsung SMD boards for the past few purchases. I have a mix of QB132s (2700k and 3500k) and one of their older 288's in 3000k. I run a few Photon Sunboards with alternating 4000k and 2700k in veg (same 301B diodes). Also in the breeding tent..I have been trying a QB288v2, 301C KNOCKOFF board(s) with excellent results. (3000k, but 9" sq as opposed to the QB 288's rectangular footprint). I will keep that Nextlight Mini until it either weakens or is no longer viable!
Click to expand...

You just made me look up photon boards, kinda cool. I love seeing all the good LED tech out there!
 
Reactions: Buzzer777
Quote Reply

Freshone

Posts
1,620
Reactions
6,140
Joined
Jul 6, 2016
Points
263
Jan 18, 2019
#39
UncleRomulus said:
I was going to just say that as well. I’ll take any 315 s anyone is selling cheap all day long. 300 watts of cobs wouldn’t even put a 315 to shame at all. I know led s are super efficient and I’m sold on em actually.. but folks do exaggerate. I was told 400 watts of led would replace a 1k hps.. ya no.. 600 maybe. Think about it this way. If one got 1 gpw off a 1k.. who’s claiming 2.5 gpw off 400 watts of cobs.. anyways what I’m getting at is there’s no need to exaggerate.. led s are sweet and all but they won’t breast feed you or anything geez haha
Click to expand...
How many 315s would you like?I think i have 7 or 8 still sitting in the shed next to the gavitas!I can ship,lol.
 
Reactions: dextr0, Dan789 and UncleRomulus
Quote Reply

Phylex

Posts
621
Reactions
1,897
Joined
Sep 1, 2018
Points
263
Jan 18, 2019
#40
3 balls said:
I get what you're saying but when I think out the math on switching over, it goes like this. Say I'm paying $50 per month per 1000W DE HPS now, IF I can get the same results from LED at 600W, 60% of $50 is still $30. If I take another 10% of for reduced AC costs, I'm down to $25 savings per month per light. I would love to save that but it would take 2 1/2 years to get that $800 savings. I don't know much about LED's other than they seem to improve the technology really fast and frequently (reminds me of Iphones), which is why I think long before my power savings cover the cost of switching, the light will be an outdated dinosaur.
Click to expand...
Damn, that's crazy. I wish my 1000W HPS bill was $50 per month. My bill went up $250. Sticker shock to say the least. I'm considering QB or COB because of it. I haven't made up my mind yet of the two.
 
Reactions: Freshone and Buzzer777
Quote Reply
Page 2 of 5 · Replies 21–40 of 88
Prev
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Next
First Prev 2 of 5 Next Last

Thread info

Replies 87
Views 18,076
Started Jan 8, 2019
Latest post Jun 26, 2020
Starter OldManRiver
Forum General Indoor Growing

Latest posts

  • 2026 Outdoor Grows! let's see em!
    • Latest: Oldchucky
    • Today at 2:01 AM
    General Outdoor Growing
  • Tumble stumbles upon a Spider Farmer clip on fan.. Growing Blue Cheese, North Thunderfuck, Cali Blues, and Bruce Banner #2
    • Latest: Tumbleweed375
    • Today at 12:11 AM
    Grow Diaries
  • itscheese`s cheese thread
    • Latest: Itscheese94
    • Yesterday at 11:30 PM
    Introduce Yourself
  • Eternal Sun 2026 outdoor garden grow
    • Latest: EternalSun
    • Yesterday at 11:28 PM
    General Outdoor Growing
  • Big Al’s 2025 season indoor/outdoor grow in misery
    • Latest: EternalSun
    • Yesterday at 11:25 PM
    Grow Diaries
  • Home
  • Forums
  • Medical Cannabis Cultivation
  • General Indoor Growing
  • Hid Vs Led - Best Thing I Have Ever Seen
  • Contact us
  • Terms and rules
  • Privacy policy
  • Help
  • Home
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2026 XenForo Ltd.
Menu
Log in

Sign up

  • Home
  • News
  • Classifieds
  • Forums
    • What's new Featured content New posts New Articles New articles New products Latest activity
  • Social
  • Strains
  • Live
  • Learn
  • Brands
X

Privacy & Transparency

We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

  • Personalized ads and content
  • Content measurement and audience insights

Do you accept cookies and these technologies?

X

Privacy & Transparency

We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

  • Personalized ads and content
  • Content measurement and audience insights

Do you accept cookies and these technologies?