• Home
  • Forums
  • Medical Cannabis Cultivation
  • Nutrients and Fertilizers
  • Let's Talk About the Calcium/Potassium See-Saw

Let's Talk About the Calcium/Potassium See-Saw

  • Thread starter Thread starter BillFarthing
  • Start date Start date Oct 25, 2020
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Let's Talk About the Calcium/Potassium See-Saw

BillFarthing Oct 25, 2020 114 Replies 24,416 Views
Page 1 of 6 · Replies 1–20 of 115
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • …
  • 6
Next
1 of 6 Next Last

BillFarthing

Supporter
Posts
472
Reactions
1,116
Joined
Jan 27, 2019
Points
143
Oct 25, 2020
#1
Calcium and potassium interact with each other and require a balancing act to work well in a plant. You can't overload a plant with one element without locking out the other.

Calcium is the engine for metabolism in the plant. It is required mostly in transition to flower. The most common source is calcium nitrate, but that is the easiest way to throw off the nitrogen balance in the plant, especially in flower. Calcium imbalance can be caused by incorrect pH, improper watering, or nutrient imbalance. In soil, it can be fixed with gypsum, lime, bone meal or compost. In hydroponics and foliar use, I prefer supplementing with calcium acetate or amino chelated calcium at transition.

Take a look at the available ppm requirements of calcium from Agrien tissue samples at the different stages of plant growth in cannabis:



Potassium is for all around health and water balance for the plant. It is required mostly in late flower. It is very easy to overload a plant with potassium in coco coir, by adding things like kelp, or potassium sulfate. Potassium deficiency can be caused by incorrect pH, excessively dry soil or nutrient imbalance.

Take a look at the available ppm requirements of potassium from Agrien tissue samples at the different stages of plant growth in cannabis:



Always do testing to help correct any issues in the root zone with a pH meter or soil test. Issues can always be minimized by starting with a high quality potting mix or balanced synthetic or organic fertilizer.
 
Reactions: MasterCookie, mikeross, Frankster and 14 others
Quote Reply

TheBioMaster

Posts
450
Reactions
602
Joined
Aug 28, 2010
Points
93
Oct 25, 2020
#2
This is true with ANY/ALL nutrition for plants.........

Shocker- you can't just dump any amount of nitrogen, calcium, phosphate or any/all other nutrients on ANY type plant, or imbalance occurs ........AND .......ph is important????????!! WOW!! Who knew???? Lol!!!

Ya know.......I bet the same rule applies to even just WATER for a plant!!!!!

Earth shaking post just full of unknown knowledge and insight bro.......
 
Reactions: Flexnerb and BillFarthing
Quote Reply

Flexnerb

Posts
1,288
Reactions
1,264
Joined
Aug 15, 2020
Points
163
Feb 27, 2021
#3
Wow! This was a great post...didnt take steam..wonder why....there should be a sticky that talks about nute imbalances how they occur, how to avoid, and how to correct the problem the right way
 
Reactions: growsince79, SeymourGreen, Grapefruitroop and 4 others
Quote Reply

SSgrower

Posts
2,374
Reactions
4,569
Joined
Dec 5, 2020
Points
263
Mar 4, 2021
#4
I am about to try Humbolt "Oneness" which is kinda like Dynagrow, I could not get DynaGrow this Monday so today I ordered the Humbolt. Anyone here familiar?
 
Quote Reply

BillFarthing

Supporter
Posts
472
Reactions
1,116
Joined
Jan 27, 2019
Points
143
Mar 4, 2021
#5
SSgrower said:
I am about to try Humbolt "Oneness" which is kinda like Dynagrow, I could not get DynaGrow this Monday so today I ordered the Humbolt. Anyone here familiar?
Click to expand...

Yes, you are going to need supplemental calcium.
 
Reactions: SSgrower
Quote Reply

Dr.Green55

Posts
577
Reactions
1,683
Joined
May 17, 2019
Points
143
Mar 8, 2021
#6
BillFarthing said:
Calcium and potassium interact with each other and require a balancing act to work well in a plant. You can't overload a plant with one element without locking out the other.

Calcium is the engine for metabolism in the plant. It is required mostly in transition to flower. The most common source is calcium nitrate, but that is the easiest way to throw off the nitrogen balance in the plant, especially in flower. Calcium imbalance can be caused by incorrect pH, improper watering, or nutrient imbalance. In soil, it can be fixed with gypsum, lime, bone meal or compost. In hydroponics and foliar use, I prefer supplementing with calcium acetate or amino chelated calcium at transition.

Take a look at the available ppm requirements of calcium from Agrien tissue samples at the different stages of plant growth in cannabis:

View attachment 1047986

Potassium is for all around health and water balance for the plant. It is required mostly in late flower. It is very easy to overload a plant with potassium in coco coir, by adding things like kelp, or potassium sulfate. Potassium deficiency can be caused by incorrect pH, excessively dry soil or nutrient imbalance.

Take a look at the available ppm requirements of potassium from Agrien tissue samples at the different stages of plant growth in cannabis:

View attachment 1047987

Always do testing to help correct any issues in the root zone with a pH meter or soil test. Issues can always be minimized by starting with a high quality potting mix or balanced synthetic or organic fertilizer.
Click to expand...


So what is your general thoughts on Ratio's of K to Mg to Ca etc, in basic veg and flower mix. I seen some varying studies from different universities. But I like the 4-2 -1, example 300ppm K 150ppm Ca and 75ppm Mg. S I usually run in the 130-140 range or whatever it comes out to, studies show it can be run up to 200ppm no issues . the only time I watch my S is if i'm doing sulfur burns.
 
Reactions: N1ghtL1ght, Arkos and BillFarthing
Quote Reply

Arkos

Posts
75
Reactions
153
Joined
Apr 8, 2021
Points
33
May 14, 2021
#7
Amazing info for numbskulls like me Thank you
 
Quote Reply

BillFarthing

Supporter
Posts
472
Reactions
1,116
Joined
Jan 27, 2019
Points
143
May 15, 2021
#8
Dr.Green55 said:
So what is your general thoughts on Ratio's of K to Mg to Ca etc, in basic veg and flower mix. I seen some varying studies from different universities. But I like the 4-2 -1, example 300ppm K 150ppm Ca and 75ppm Mg. S I usually run in the 130-140 range or whatever it comes out to, studies show it can be run up to 200ppm no issues . the only time I watch my S is if i'm doing sulfur burns.
Click to expand...
~125 N, 40 P, 175 K, 150 Ca, 50 Mg, 60 S, 2.8 Fe and micros. A lot of this is moot when you use a high quality fulvic with chelated and complexed micros and your pH is in check.
 
Reactions: likeysam319, Frankster, SeymourGreen and 3 others
Quote Reply

SeymourGreen

Posts
82
Reactions
90
Joined
May 4, 2018
Points
18
Jul 6, 2021
#9
BillFarthing said:
~125 N, 40 P, 175 K, 150 Ca, 50 Mg, 60 S, 2.8 Fe and micros. A lot of this is moot when you use a high quality fulvic with chelated and complexed micros and your pH is in check.
Click to expand...
Do you recommend this for all stages of growth, or just veg?
 
Quote Reply

BillFarthing

Supporter
Posts
472
Reactions
1,116
Joined
Jan 27, 2019
Points
143
Jul 6, 2021
#10
SeymourGreen said:
Do you recommend this for all stages of growth, or just veg?
Click to expand...
The ratio, yes. The EC is going to change between tiny plants, veg and flower.
 
Reactions: Arkos and SeymourGreen
Quote Reply

SeymourGreen

Posts
82
Reactions
90
Joined
May 4, 2018
Points
18
Jul 6, 2021
#11
Thanks for the reply. Is this close to the same ratio then as the “Recipe”? Really want to give that a try in a run or two.
 
Quote Reply

jguit

Supporter
Posts
905
Reactions
1,675
Joined
Feb 27, 2018
Points
143
Jul 6, 2021
#12
SeymourGreen said:
Thanks for the reply. Is this close to the same ratio then as the “Recipe”? Really want to give that a try in a run or two.
Click to expand...
It's pretty close. PK levels are a little bit higher (and Ca levels a bit lower) w/ Jack's 321. Don't overthink it.

Useful Calculation: 3000mg (weight of Jack's Part A per gallon converted to mg) / 3.78 (liters per gallon) * .12 (percentage of P in Jack's Part A 5-12-26) = 95 ppm of P
 
Last edited: Jul 6, 2021
Reactions: likeysam319, M0nStarNuggety and SeymourGreen
Quote Reply

SeymourGreen

Posts
82
Reactions
90
Joined
May 4, 2018
Points
18
Jul 6, 2021
#13
jguit said:
jguit said:
It's pretty close. PK levels are a little bit higher (and Ca levels a bit lower) w/ Jack's 321. Don't overthink it.

Useful Calculation: 3000mg (weight of Jack's Part A per gallon converted to mg) / 3.78 (liters per gallon) * .12 (percentage of P in Jack's Part A 5-12-26) = 95 ppm of P
Click to expand...
Thanks for this. Been having a buddy run numbers for me on the angelfire calculator. Another quick question if you don’t mind. How is everyone adjusting the Ec with Jacks? Mix it up full strength, and then just dilute to target Ec?
Click to expand...
 
Quote Reply

jguit

Supporter
Posts
905
Reactions
1,675
Joined
Feb 27, 2018
Points
143
Jul 6, 2021
#14
Thanks for this. Been having a buddy run numbers for me on the angelfire calculator. Another quick question if you don’t mind. How is everyone adjusting the Ec with Jacks? Mix it up full strength, and then just dilute to target Ec?
Click to expand...

You can simply dilute or adjust the weight of salts you add. For example, if you wanted 80% strength, just do the math 3g * .80 = 2.4g, 2g * .80 = 1.6g, etc... Whatever works easier for you!
 
Reactions: SeymourGreen and M0nStarNuggety
Quote Reply

SeymourGreen

Posts
82
Reactions
90
Joined
May 4, 2018
Points
18
Jul 6, 2021
#15
Awesome! Thank you very much. That helps tremendously!
 
Quote Reply

extractoilminussixty

Posts
295
Reactions
1,080
Joined
Jul 6, 2021
Points
143
Jul 6, 2021
#16
BillFarthing said:
Calcium and potassium interact with each other and require a balancing act to work well in a plant. You can't overload a plant with one element without locking out the other.

Calcium is the engine for metabolism in the plant. It is required mostly in transition to flower. The most common source is calcium nitrate, but that is the easiest way to throw off the nitrogen balance in the plant, especially in flower. Calcium imbalance can be caused by incorrect pH, improper watering, or nutrient imbalance. In soil, it can be fixed with gypsum, lime, bone meal or compost. In hydroponics and foliar use, I prefer supplementing with calcium acetate or amino chelated calcium at transition.

Take a look at the available ppm requirements of calcium from Agrien tissue samples at the different stages of plant growth in cannabis:

View attachment 1047986

Potassium is for all around health and water balance for the plant. It is required mostly in late flower. It is very easy to overload a plant with potassium in coco coir, by adding things like kelp, or potassium sulfate. Potassium deficiency can be caused by incorrect pH, excessively dry soil or nutrient imbalance.

Take a look at the available ppm requirements of potassium from Agrien tissue samples at the different stages of plant growth in cannabis:

View attachment 1047987

Always do testing to help correct any issues in the root zone with a pH meter or soil test. Issues can always be minimized by starting with a high quality potting mix or balanced synthetic or organic fertilizer.
Click to expand...
Great graph thank you, really shows a picture is worth a thousand grows (I mean words)

(Seriously been showing it to new Med growers in MO., it’s like the lightbulb turned on, u can read read read, but the graph sums it up)
 
Reactions: SeymourGreen
Quote Reply

jguit

Supporter
Posts
905
Reactions
1,675
Joined
Feb 27, 2018
Points
143
Jul 6, 2021
#17
I need to correct my post above. Jack's 321 would contain approx 40 ppm of P (If mixed at 3g of Part A). I forgot to account that the label shows the percentage of P2O5 (not P). Same thing for K.

  • P2O5 = 43% P
  • K2O = 83% K

So yea, Jack's 321 would be very close to the values BillFarthing mentioned above. Sorry for the mixup.
 
Last edited: Jul 6, 2021
Reactions: boatbum850 and SeymourGreen
Quote Reply

SeymourGreen

Posts
82
Reactions
90
Joined
May 4, 2018
Points
18
Jul 6, 2021
#18
jguit said:
I need to correct my post above. Jack's 321 would contain approx 40 ppm of P (If mixed at 3g of Part A). I forgot to account that the label shows the percentage of P2O5 (not P). Same thing for K.

  • P2O5 = 43% P
  • K2O = 83% K

So yea, Jack's 321 would be very close to the values BillFarthing mentioned above. Sorry for the mixup.
Click to expand...
No biggie. Appreciate the clarification.
 
Reactions: SSgrower and jguit
Quote Reply

Skybound

Posts
63
Reactions
95
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
Points
18
Jul 12, 2021
#19
Check out THIS blog entry by Dr Daniel Fernandez regarding how nutrient manufacturers can misrepresent their formulations in their so called Guaranteed Analysis. That being said, don't trust the label info as it's intentionally skewed to protect their formulation(s). I journal my grow at the Bean Basement and sometimes 420, but I also made a "How To" video on YouTube for using Hydro Buddy that might be helpful to some, but generally, I've found it easier to just stay in my own lane and not be influenced by product labels with skewed info. I developed a PH Perfect regimen for my perpetual garden that yields me a plant every week, and the good thing about a setup like that is that I have plants in all stages of life at all times, so change I make along the way show results in about 2 weeks. I'll share my most current targets and which solutions I used to achieve them. PH perfection is gained by balancing the potassium silicate with the monoammonium phosphate (MAP), and starting from my RO source, these targets result in perfect PH stability at about 5.9-6.0.




FYI, using the Late regimen on plants with yellow leaves will yellow EVERY leaf on the plant, so I choose whether to stay using the Mid or graduate to the Late on a plant by plant, feed by feed basis.

This is a really good thread so I logged in to contribute as well as learn.

Edit - I forgot to mention that I mix everything (except micros) at 1 gram for every 10ml of RO in the jug. Because I make half gallons, for me, that's 189.27 grams which I round up to 189.3 grams on my 0.0 scale. Micros, I target by themselves and tell Hydro Buddy that I'm using a 1000x more than what I am, than shove it all into the one jug, so once again for my half gallon jug, I tell HB I'm making 500 gallons. This is my micro mix made with chelated metals Iron DTPA, Manganese EDTA, Copper EDTA, Zinc EDTA, Boric Acid and Sodium Molybdate. 3.8 on the above chart means I'm dosing my feed stock (DTW) at 3.8ml/Gal. Everything else is also Ml/Gal.

 
Last edited: Jul 12, 2021
Reactions: SeymourGreen
Quote Reply

SSgrower

Posts
2,374
Reactions
4,569
Joined
Dec 5, 2020
Points
263
Jul 12, 2021
#20
BillFarthing said:
Yes, you are going to need supplemental calcium.
Click to expand...
I use Botnicare Cal/mag plus iron.
 
Quote Reply
Page 1 of 6 · Replies 1–20 of 115
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • …
  • 6
Next
1 of 6 Next Last

Thread info

Replies 114
Views 24,416
Started Oct 25, 2020
Latest post Jun 19, 2022
Starter BillFarthing
Forum Nutrients and Fertilizers

Latest posts

  • Outdoor Gardeners / Growers. Let's Talk-Show Gardens-Soil-Methods-Pests-Critters-Gardening Kind Of Stuff!
    • Latest: grayoldnproud
    • 28 minutes ago
    Other Pics
  • 40 days into cure , no change in smell or flavor
    • Latest: Hotblondz13
    • 49 minutes ago
    Cannabis Infirmary
  • B
    New grower need advice on my plant
    • Latest: Brian804
    • 59 minutes ago
    Basic Growing Information
  • Cpurola's Outdoor grow in Southeast Michigan 2026
    • Latest: grayoldnproud
    • Today at 5:19 PM
    General Outdoor Growing
  • I
    Mars Hydro API reverse engineered
    • Latest: Inzemix
    • Today at 5:18 PM
    Growroom Design & Setup
  • Home
  • Forums
  • Medical Cannabis Cultivation
  • Nutrients and Fertilizers
  • Let's Talk About the Calcium/Potassium See-Saw
  • Contact us
  • Terms and rules
  • Privacy policy
  • Help
  • Home
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2026 XenForo Ltd.
Menu
Log in

Sign up

  • Home
  • News
  • Classifieds
  • Forums
    • What's new Featured content New posts New Articles New articles New products Latest activity
  • Social
  • Strains
  • Live
  • Learn
  • Brands
X

Privacy & Transparency

We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

  • Personalized ads and content
  • Content measurement and audience insights

Do you accept cookies and these technologies?

X

Privacy & Transparency

We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

  • Personalized ads and content
  • Content measurement and audience insights

Do you accept cookies and these technologies?