PH A Basic explanation

  • Thread starter Aqua Man
  • Start date
  • Tagged users None
Madmax

Madmax

4,034
263
I tossed it out 😃..is there anything on the subject you have read aqua that iron and cal precipiate out of solution when they are added after si ..see how i dont listen even when your right..lol..
 
Last edited:
Aqua Man

Aqua Man

Staff
Supporter
21,300
638
I tossed it out 😃..is there anything on the subject you have read aqua that iron and cal precipiate out of solution when they are added after si ..see how i dont listen lol even when your right..lol..
Just got off work... not sure how ya mixed em but will check back when I wake up.
 
edray2052

edray2052

7
3
So is the general takeaway here that if you're using a pH adjusted soil (I'm in ocean forest), and you're not using silica and you're water isn't too far from neutral (my tap runs around 7.1-7.2), then you're better off not using pH up or down? My first FFOF grow I didn't know anything about pH -- my second grow I've been pHing every watering/feed and my plants don't look nearly as good as when I wasn't worrying about it. Could be an infinite number of reasons for that I guess, but after reading this thread I'm inclined to box up my pH Up/Down.
 
XtreemLee

XtreemLee

13
3
To confirm my well water comes out at ph of 8 and an ec of .4. I’m using bubble buckets I flushed the media and plant root with sledgehammer/water mix. I then put the plants in plain water ph balanced to 6.0, and verified ec at .37 with no nutrients. I just want to watch my ph for a day or two before adding any nutes.
I have some cal/mag (fox farm) coming, I expect that to help moderate my ph. I definitely have been adding to much nutrients. Since my roots are in water what should my vegetative ec be? I’ve seen some that say never over 1.2, but am not sure.
 
HarryHood

HarryHood

251
43
So is the general takeaway here that if you're using a pH adjusted soil (I'm in ocean forest), and you're not using silica and you're water isn't too far from neutral (my tap runs around 7.1-7.2), then you're better off not using pH up or down? My first FFOF grow I didn't know anything about pH -- my second grow I've been pHing every watering/feed and my plants don't look nearly as good as when I wasn't worrying about it. Could be an infinite number of reasons for that I guess, but after reading this thread I'm inclined to box up my pH Up/Down.
yeah, i think that's the case, but i'm a newb so take that fwiw?
 
Aqua Man

Aqua Man

Staff
Supporter
21,300
638
So is the general takeaway here that if you're using a pH adjusted soil (I'm in ocean forest), and you're not using silica and you're water isn't too far from neutral (my tap runs around 7.1-7.2), then you're better off not using pH up or down? My first FFOF grow I didn't know anything about pH -- my second grow I've been pHing every watering/feed and my plants don't look nearly as good as when I wasn't worrying about it. Could be an infinite number of reasons for that I guess, but after reading this thread I'm inclined to box up my pH Up/Down.
Imo yes.
 
Aqua Man

Aqua Man

Staff
Supporter
21,300
638
To confirm my well water comes out at ph of 8 and an ec of .4. I’m using bubble buckets I flushed the media and plant root with sledgehammer/water mix. I then put the plants in plain water ph balanced to 6.0, and verified ec at .37 with no nutrients. I just want to watch my ph for a day or two before adding any nutes.
I have some cal/mag (fox farm) coming, I expect that to help moderate my ph. I definitely have been adding to much nutrients. Since my roots are in water what should my vegetative ec be? I’ve seen some that say never over 1.2, but am not sure.
Every grow will be different... read the plants is the best way but typically 1.2-1.4 mid to late veg. May need a water only day in there but hard to say
 
Madmax

Madmax

4,034
263
This is what i seen a while back and the reason why im doing it like i am bar using cal mag where he mentions as i read somewhere si and cal mag dont go well together like that.i use cal mag at end when i do ..but i wont use them in same feed.
Screenshot_20210113-144919.jpg
 
Last edited:
KingHale

KingHale

61
18
Over the past week I’ve been running a test to figure out if there’s a reason to pH balance the water/nutrients i feed my plants.

I have 39 clones and a soil pH meter

half of the clones got pH balanced water and nutrients, the other half just got water and nutrients. Here are my findings:

The clones who received pH balanced water maintained a soil pH of right around 6.0
The clones who did not receive pH balanced water all had soils whose measurements maxed the needle of my pH meter, so their soil was at least 8.0.

All Of the plants look healthy. I don’t see any distinguishable difference between them.

As much as I’d love to skip the step of having to pH balance everything, I think for now I’m going to continue doing it. I just thought I’d share my findings.
 
Aqua Man

Aqua Man

Staff
Supporter
21,300
638
Over the past week I’ve been running a test to figure out if there’s a reason to pH balance the water/nutrients i feed my plants.

I have 39 clones and a soil pH meter

half of the clones got pH balanced water and nutrients, the other half just got water and nutrients. Here are my findings:

The clones who received pH balanced water maintained a soil pH of right around 6.0
The clones who did not receive pH balanced water all had soils whose measurements maxed the needle of my pH meter, so their soil was at least 8.0.

All Of the plants look healthy. I don’t see any distinguishable difference between them.

As much as I’d love to skip the step of having to pH balance everything, I think for now I’m going to continue doing it. I just thought I’d share my findings.
Testing right after watering?
 
Aqua Man

Aqua Man

Staff
Supporter
21,300
638
Over the past week I’ve been running a test to figure out if there’s a reason to pH balance the water/nutrients i feed my plants.

I have 39 clones and a soil pH meter

half of the clones got pH balanced water and nutrients, the other half just got water and nutrients. Here are my findings:

The clones who received pH balanced water maintained a soil pH of right around 6.0
The clones who did not receive pH balanced water all had soils whose measurements maxed the needle of my pH meter, so their soil was at least 8.0.

All Of the plants look healthy. I don’t see any distinguishable difference between them.

As much as I’d love to skip the step of having to pH balance everything, I think for now I’m going to continue doing it. I just thought I’d share my findings.
Kinda curious what water source and nutrients your using that would give you a ph of 8 after mixing.
 
Glassdub

Glassdub

895
143
My run offs have been acid which I attribute to aciding down tap water to be "in range" but putting the root zone out of range, I won't make this mistake again unless the root zone goes high out of range.
 
HarryHood

HarryHood

251
43
Over the past week I’ve been running a test to figure out if there’s a reason to pH balance the water/nutrients i feed my plants.

I have 39 clones and a soil pH meter

half of the clones got pH balanced water and nutrients, the other half just got water and nutrients. Here are my findings:

The clones who received pH balanced water maintained a soil pH of right around 6.0
The clones who did not receive pH balanced water all had soils whose measurements maxed the needle of my pH meter, so their soil was at least 8.0.

All Of the plants look healthy. I don’t see any distinguishable difference between them.

As much as I’d love to skip the step of having to pH balance everything, I think for now I’m going to continue doing it. I just thought I’d share my findings.
wow! that's interesting 🤔
 
TheForechecker

TheForechecker

20
3
I have had a lot of PH lockout since I started in September. I have a list of about 10 DIFFERENT things I've done to abuse the plants, so its not even worth going there (soil, light, air, water? where do you want to start?). I grew some pretty crappy weed, but now I know what these plants can take and its quite impressive. 🤟

The water here is 7.8ph and 800ish ppm, its hard water with a lot of cal/mag.

I have started to use RO water (20ppm) and then just put about 1/3 or 1/4 of tap water (which run through an anti-scale whole house filter as well), enough to get the PPM to 75-150ppm.

I use living soil and top dress the glandular amendments. In the water, in the past, I've added epson salt, cal/mag, molasses, silica, mycos and phdown. Now I'm just recovering from nute lockout on my current grows that's in week 6 of flowering (from adding all that crap AND nutes AFTER lockout 😕 lmao). I have 10 plants coming out of veg stage soon...going treat these gals like queens! I promise ill try.

My question is because I am adding in this 100ppm of cal/mag from tap water, should I still add the 60ppm of general hydroponics CAL/mag with every watering? Its better to add the tap water because of the buffering qualities, eh? Also, I'm afraid I'm killing bennies that cal/mag liquid nute, but I have it and ill use it if I need it.
 
Aqua Man

Aqua Man

Staff
Supporter
21,300
638
I have had a lot of PH lockout since I started in September. I have a list of about 10 DIFFERENT things I've done to abuse the plants, so its not even worth going there (soil, light, air, water? where do you want to start?). I grew some pretty crappy weed, but now I know what these plants can take and its quite impressive. 🤟

The water here is 7.8ph and 800ish ppm, its hard water with a lot of cal/mag.

I have started to use RO water (20ppm) and then just put about 1/3 or 1/4 of tap water (which run through an anti-scale whole house filter as well), enough to get the PPM to 75-150ppm.

I use living soil and top dress the glandular amendments. In the water, in the past, I've added epson salt, cal/mag, molasses, silica, mycos and phdown. Now I'm just recovering from nute lockout on my current grows that's in week 6 of flowering (from adding all that crap AND nutes AFTER lockout 😕 lmao). I have 10 plants coming out of veg stage soon...going treat these gals like queens! I promise ill try.

My question is because I am adding in this 100ppm of cal/mag from tap water, should I still add the 60ppm of general hydroponics CAL/mag with every watering? Its better to add the tap water because of the buffering qualities, eh? Also, I'm afraid I'm killing bennies that cal/mag liquid nute, but I have it and ill use it if I need it.
Ummm quick question first... is that whole house unit by chance a water softener? If it is and it sounds like it is then thats probably the root of all your problems
 
Glassdub

Glassdub

895
143
My question is because I am adding in this 100ppm of cal/mag from tap water, should I still add the 60ppm of general hydroponics CAL/mag with every watering? Its better to add the tap water because of the buffering qualities, eh? Also, I'm afraid I'm killing bennies that cal/mag liquid nute, but I have it and ill use it if I need it.

This is a question I've been trying to get an answer to, being the high level of city lime in my tap water, not this high my tap ppms are under 100 but pH is usually 10.5, would I really need to supplement Cal, is the tap lime plant available?
 
TheForechecker

TheForechecker

20
3
Ummm quick question first... is that whole house unit by chance a water softener? If it is and it sounds like it is then thats probably the root of all your problems

So my system: town water to> water softener > express water - whole house anti-scale filtration system> express water - reverse osmosis> then I normally bubble it overnight before PHing
 
Aqua Man

Aqua Man

Staff
Supporter
21,300
638
So my system: town water to> water softener > express water - whole house anti-scale filtration system> express water - reverse osmosis> then I normally bubble it overnight before PHing
What's the ppm of the RO water?

I would not add any water that's been through through water softener back into the mix.

It exchanges minerals like calcium, magnesium etc for sodium.. in small does its a micro nutrient but it quickly becomes toxic at lower levels... we want to keep sodium well below 25ppm with all contributions including ferts, additives etc.

So IMO you can assume any ppm post water softener is sodium.
 
Aqua Man

Aqua Man

Staff
Supporter
21,300
638
This is a question I've been trying to get an answer to, being the high level of city lime in my tap water, not this high my tap ppms are under 100 but pH is usually 10.5, would I really need to supplement Cal, is the tap lime plant available?
So you may and may not depending on the makeup... like I say in my original post PH is not really something you can use on its own.

You can look up your water report or post it here and I can give you the low down on it.

But to answer typically the ratio of calcium to Mg is not adequate in tap water... most times you will find adequate calcium but very much lacking magnesium and as we know the nutrient ratios are extremely important to maintain. So in this case instead of adding cal mag you only need to add Mg to bring the ratio back. Ideally about 100ppm Cal and 50ppm of Mg. In most cases if you ppm from tap is between 100-200ppm simply adding 1 gram per gal of magnesium sulfate (epsom salt) will bring the ratios back into a favorable place.
 
TheForechecker

TheForechecker

20
3
What's the ppm of the RO water?

I would not add any water that's been through through water softener back into the mix.

It exchanges minerals like calcium, magnesium etc for sodium.. in small does its a micro nutrient but it quickly becomes toxic at lower levels... we want to keep sodium well below 25ppm with all contributions including ferts, additives etc.

So IMO you can assume any ppm post water softener is sodium.
Its about 20ppm coming out of RO (That 20ppm is from the alkaline stage (The 5th-9th stages are our Alkaline Filter adding 5 stages of mineralization, antioxidants, and oxygen to your water. )
800ppm when tested after running through entire system
and oddly enough its 800ppm when tested directly from town (outdoor faucet). Its very easy for me to tap into a direct town water line as well if some of that water would be beneficial.

So, what do you think would be my safest path forward to experiment with in my new living soil run? Straight RO water, then add cal/mag or epson salt as plant show deficiency? I think you are correct and it makes total sense about salt being the primary TDS in my (non-RO) water, not cal/mag.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom