MW7945
- 3,269
- 263
Not quite sure if this is the right section for this, but does anyone have a copy of this? Pretty new to this stuff still and this seems to be about the most complete book out there. Just curious if it's worth the $45
Not likely, there isn't a pdf/e-book version of it that I'm aware of. I don't really care to ready on computer or tablets anyways. Makes it difficult to navigate quickly and so on. A pdf version would likely be over 1000 pages, this thing is huge
Interesting list though. I see Jorge's older book is on there. This one is only a 2 years old or so. It likely isn't digital due to how easy it is to share/pirate it
are u for real how long u been holding on to that jewel
I prefer books too. But new ones are expensive.
Reading Ed Rosenthals growing tips now.
how funny so was I also finding not all of them load for me
For sure. It's about $45 on amazon, but I figure it's arguably the most complete one out there from what I can tell. Should be about the only one I need unless I need something more specific. Which I might be able to find on that list
Was between his and this one, but this one was the newest one. I have a kindle so I can get those for a pretty good price, but I really wanted a physical book
Reading Ed Rosenthals growing tips now.
From what I gathered a lot of people thought Ed's book was TOO much science. And kind of strayed away from some of the basic information. I'm all about science, but I don't need to know everything down to a T when it comes to the plant really. Basically it comes down to there not really being a one size fits all for this type of thing. I ordered this book so we'll see how it goes. Should be here tomorrow
There's still plenty of science in this from what I gather. I agree, you can never learn too much.
I own that encyclopedia and it is very good about getting in depth with the basics. Yes Jorge does say some really silly misleading facts but they are far and few between. And yes he is mostly a reporter, and most of the knowledge in there are from other growers (even a very large "thanks to" in the beginning of it)
After reading it a couple dozen times (which I recommend you do also because I learned something new that I didn't previously understand every time and it boosted my knowledge immensely)
Ed is very scientific and I would definitely say some of his offerings is geared toward the "advanced" grower, but he does have the most relevant info for sure.
Best of luck, the knowledge game is real.
@mandalaman bro this needs stickied! Awesome wealth of info, awesome post brother!
@mandalaman bro this needs stickied! Awesome wealth of info, awesome post brother!