How long have you been cooling your gardens with water instead of air?? Do you have any pics of your setup? Water seems to be the way to go by what you guys are saying, I've been busy the last 10 days but am getting caught up and now think its time to start another project. Life always in a constant state of change.
It's been two full years since I got it installed and in all that time, the only failure was when a totally incompetent HVAC tech broke it while guessing instead of actually diagnosing whether the machine was in need of service. It didn't. Lesson learned? Make Damn sure you get a tech who knows wtf they're doing! Nothing new about that!
My chiller was originally manufactured as an AC unit, complete with an EER rating of 14.3. Hydro Innovations bought it and modified into a chiller, as follows; they removed the evaporator coil and fan, and installed a water pigtail, with the Freon line running through it. Water passes through the cool and is cooled by the exact same compressor, compressor section (hot side radiator) and other components of a standard AC unit, because in all respects besides the water pigtail, IT IS ONE. This is an important point; to understand that a chiller is not a fundamentally different device from AC.
So, why is it so much more efficient? That water passing through it picks up the temperature change more readily than air does, because it's some 900 times more thermally dense than air. Because of this thermal mass, it can carry a heat load (positive or negative) much further than AC, even with ducting. It isn't the compressor that's more efficient, it's the fact that this device uses a better medium to move heat around than air.
The benefits multiply in Controlled Environment Agriculture (CEA), because of the technology's total control over humidity. The water passing through the system effectively sets the dewpoint for your garden; set your dewpoint, set your RH. If you run RDWC, then water chilling is the assumptive best option due to its unique ability to keep water at a set temperature.
All the above accrues when you chill water instead of air. Now, let's touch on what happens if you put all that heat into another water circuit instead of just blowing it outside through a radiator. This is called 'water cooled process chilling', and it is NOT a heat pump. It just takes all the heat it's pulling out of the water on one side and puts it into a separate hot water circuit. This circuit could simultaneously service your hot water tank for domestic use, heat your home, heat your hot tub (directly replacing electrical use!), outdoor fish tanks for aquaculture or aquaponics, even geothermal applications like running lines under a driveway to heat it in winter. No more shoveling!