Log In Register
  • Thread starter Thread starter AthelR
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

What to do about the smell of a ripe plant?

AthelR 28 Replies 2,683 Views
Page 2 of 2 · Replies 21–29 of 29
For anyone interested, I’ve decided doing nothing carries too great a risk. The plant is now pushing 2.5m height and taking up most of 4square metres. We’re expecting a lot of colas. It’s going to pong.
So I am investing in a length of 10cm flexible duct, an inline fan, and 10k of activated charcoal. This will draw air out of the polytunnel, into a 1m square sump 15cm deep. This wil be covered by a mesh holding a 2cm layer of charcoal, and above that the deodorised air will be released. Actually, this will benefit the plant, because air circulation in the tunnel is not great… I can only hope this system is effective - I know very little about air duct systems or activated charcoal. If anyone has any expert comments I would welcome that. And thanks to everyone who has already commented.
Definitely not an expert comment but I have used a charcoal filters before with great results.

Nice work! Hope it helps your situation a bit! If you feel like it, come back for an update of how it works! : ) ✌️
 
We are in southern England. We have a very healthy plant in a polytunnel. I’m looking ahead and worrying about people smelling our plant when it’s nearing harvest time. We are a few metres from a country road. With neighbours not far away. I’ve attached a ground plan which explains everything.

Ideas I’ve had are : sealing the door of the polytunnel during the day and open late at night when hopefully no-one is about, creating a vent with ducting pipe taking the smell away from the road/neighbours, and some sort of charcoal filter in the door. Will it harm the plants for them to be sealed in most of the day? View attachment 2493251

Does anyone have other ideas or comments? Thanks!

Start by creating a soft negative pressure in that polytunnel. For your exhaust, mount the fan mid-height or up in the rafters, then duct that air away from the road and down to ground level. You want to terminate it low into some dense shrubs or a mulch bed - the soil biology and vegetation will help scrub any trace odors before they can drift.

On the opposite end, cut a passive intake low to the ground with bug screen and a backdraft flap. This creates a nice front-to-back cross-flow that pulls air away from the road. Keep this running 24/7 on a low setting - odor actually spikes when the lights go off, so you need that constant flow.

For sizing, here's what works in polytunnels: They leak a bit naturally, so you're aiming for about 10-20 air changes per hour - not the crazy 1-2 per minute you'd see in tiny tents. As a rule of thumb, a 150mm (6-inch) mixed-flow fan with a matching carbon can handles most small garden tunnels. Go up to 200mm (8-inch) if you've got a larger volume or long duct runs. Keep those duct runs short with gentle bends, and add an inline silencer if noise becomes an issue.

If you're still getting some smell breakthrough, here's a trick I've used: add an internal scrubber loop. This is a second filter and fan that just recirculates air inside the tunnel without exhausting anything outside. It constantly strips odor without increasing your exhaust rate - great insurance policy for late flower when things get really pungent.

For camouflage around your outlet area, plant some strong aromatic plants like rosemary, mint, or lavender. I've even seen folks use ornamental alliums like another member suggested. This doesn't eliminate odor, but it gives you a believable source if there's a faint whiff in the area.

Now, about drying - this is usually the smelliest week of the whole process. If you can dry indoors with its own filter setup, that's your best bet. If you must dry in the tunnel, drop your fan speed but keep that filter running, and try to hold around 60-65°F with 55-60% humidity - still exhausting away from the road.

About your DIY charcoal sump idea: I appreciate the creativity, and it's not a bad concept, but to make it work properly you'd need much deeper carbon, uniform airflow distribution, and a sealed plenum system. By the time you build all that correctly, you've basically created a carbon can in disguise. A ready-made filter will be simpler, safer, and likely cheaper than buying 10kg of loose carbon once you factor in building the housing right.
 
I don't know if ornamental onions will grow well where you are but they may help. We have them in our front yard and any time out there weed wacking in the planter it smells like a skunk strain. Won't mask the smell, just provide an excuse for it.
Thanks again! Something to disguise the smell would be a good idea too. What can we throw on the compost heap which will smell when it decomposes? 🤔
 
I previously offered up a genuine suggestion and now I'll say what I was originally thinking.

What to do about the smell of a ripe plant? How about... enjoy it, lol
 
Start by creating a soft negative pressure in that polytunnel. For your exhaust, mount the fan mid-height or up in the rafters, then duct that air away from the road and down to ground level. You want to terminate it low into some dense shrubs or a mulch bed - the soil biology and vegetation will help scrub any trace odors before they can drift.

On the opposite end, cut a passive intake low to the ground with bug screen and a backdraft flap. This creates a nice front-to-back cross-flow that pulls air away from the road. Keep this running 24/7 on a low setting - odor actually spikes when the lights go off, so you need that constant flow.

For sizing, here's what works in polytunnels: They leak a bit naturally, so you're aiming for about 10-20 air changes per hour - not the crazy 1-2 per minute you'd see in tiny tents. As a rule of thumb, a 150mm (6-inch) mixed-flow fan with a matching carbon can handles most small garden tunnels. Go up to 200mm (8-inch) if you've got a larger volume or long duct runs. Keep those duct runs short with gentle bends, and add an inline silencer if noise becomes an issue.

If you're still getting some smell breakthrough, here's a trick I've used: add an internal scrubber loop. This is a second filter and fan that just recirculates air inside the tunnel without exhausting anything outside. It constantly strips odor without increasing your exhaust rate - great insurance policy for late flower when things get really pungent.

For camouflage around your outlet area, plant some strong aromatic plants like rosemary, mint, or lavender. I've even seen folks use ornamental alliums like another member suggested. This doesn't eliminate odor, but it gives you a believable source if there's a faint whiff in the area.

Now, about drying - this is usually the smelliest week of the whole process. If you can dry indoors with its own filter setup, that's your best bet. If you must dry in the tunnel, drop your fan speed but keep that filter running, and try to hold around 60-65°F with 55-60% humidity - still exhausting away from the road.

About your DIY charcoal sump idea: I appreciate the creativity, and it's not a bad concept, but to make it work properly you'd need much deeper carbon, uniform airflow distribution, and a sealed plenum system. By the time you build all that correctly, you've basically created a carbon can in disguise. A ready-made filter will be simpler, safer, and likely cheaper than buying 10kg of loose carbon once you factor in building the housing right.
Thanks Randy. I will look into what you call a carbon can, also a scrubber loop. I will do some more research…we can dry indoors in a sealed room. Thanks for the tip about night times. I have a compost heap I can send the air into, but I’m thinking that if I up the back pressure the fan may not be able to cope.
 
I previously offered up a genuine suggestion and now I'll say what I was originally thinking.

What to do about the smell of a ripe plant? How about... enjoy it, lol
I would - passers by might be arsey and suspicious.
 
Do-It-Yourself woodworkers devise techniques for dust control that are similar to odor control. One method is to make a box with square fan and readily-available filters. DIY websites provide surprisingly creative examples. Here are some images from a Google search. They're effective, inexpensive, and easy to build. Hardware stores usually have many different filters that are replacements for home HVac systems that can be used for this purpose.

1754845113798


1754845151949


1754845203645
 
Every week replace a squashed skunk in the road in front of the house.
Yer on your own sourcing squashed skunks.
But seriously cover smell. What is a very noticeable loud plant like honeysuckle or wisteria hedges or the like. Might not help this run and will take planning. Heck there are a couple of tomatoes I have grown that you could smells from meters away.
I don’t think they have skunks over there lol you’re gunna have to be the skunk plug
 
Page 2 of 2 · Replies 21–29 of 29
Back
Top Bottom