Neither
Superthrive or teas are actual fertilizer. You
can put fertilizer in water and call it tea, but actually AACT is a method of producing microorganisms, which in turn convert organics fertilizers into plant available nutrients (over time). Normally a tea will contain stuff like kelp and fish hydrolysate, which are beneficial for your plants, but in a very low amount as it's actually for the gritters, not for your plants. (You might only have a few tablespoons of either in 5 gallons.) I've got no idea what is actually in the "tea" you have and assume it's a commercial product that isn't actually a tea. Not saying it's a shit product, but rather suggesting it may not be providing much nutrients (and almost always is slow acting).
The
Superthrive is hormones and vitamins (and debatable if it does diddle). Once again if you want to use it, no problem, but it's not a fertilizer (or substitute for). So if you're looking for a quick fix, then you need to apply the actually nutrients you think you need. As has been mentioned pee in water is a better source of nitrogen then tea or ST. Most other organics are going to be slow acting. So you might just go with any of the major nutrient bottles like Dynagrow, Bonanical, Megacrop,
General Hydroponics, etc. They all have a standard veg formula that will do the trick.
And don't forget that most organics will not register on a TDS/EC/PPM meter. So if you're using organics, you could have a super hot pot and still show a very low reading on your meter. So don't use it as a definitive guide if mixing and matching organics and salt based ferts.