Tell me something friend, in your opinion is darker shatter not as tasty as some yellow?
You asked my
opinion And this is it.
I think a lot of the taste depends on the strain or the extraction method.
For example my iso extractions come out darker than most but still taste amazing because it's a full extraction with all the cannabinoids, but has a tiny % of plant matter.
But a distillate can be very pure, clean & refined yet only contain parts of the cannabinoid profile with
terpenes removed.
So taste isn't always what I'd be looking at. It's what your expecting to receive in the cannabinoid profile.
The strain will determine the profile along with the flavor,
terpenes, color etc. And the extraction method will determine what the final product looks & tastes like after being refined.
Some strains produce different colors of extracted oil.
I would research the different extraction methods and get an idea of how each one works.
From what I've heard rosin is the best flavor wise and with no solvents used it's one of the cleanest.
The last step after extraction for max purity is short path distillation. which uses different temp set points to vaporize the different chemical compounds to seperate them and recondense them into seperate containers.
This is very clean and can isolate pure thc, cbd , etc. Which flavor wise is great but you'd be missing out on the terps and the full profile flavors.
So it mostly comes down down to preference on what kind of high or taste you want to enjoy.
I know my answers aren't always exact. But I've noticed most things in life are relative and can have many different outcomes dependant upon each situation or individual.
Going from a consumer perspective. I'd stick to the yellow shatter because it has the potential to be a more pure product.
I've also seen that distillate usually comes out amber in color but it is not shatter.
Both forms are clean and good, but as you can see color varies between processes.
Color can also be affected by shorter or longer flowering times causing the trichomes to ripen and turn more amber, or be more clear and less ripe.
If your growing your own plants and extracting your own oil. I would not worry about color at all.