How valuable is my tea in super soil?

  • Thread starter Dunge
  • Start date
  • Tagged users None
Seamaiden

Seamaiden

Living dead girl
23,596
638
I would have thought that this report would generated more interest.
With all the effort I and others put into brewing tea, the thought that our plants are not benefiting from the attention should stimulate some controversy.

First off, we can question my tea formulation and habit of using it in every watering start to finish.
This is not that hard a demonstration to duplicate.
I'd like to see an example of a soil/tea formulation that does show improved plant performance.
It is my conclusion that my soil formulation is fully populated with microbes and that the plants are getting all the nutrients they can use without tea.
I didn't really want to say anything at this point, but I've wondered just how useful constantly applying teas really is. I'm a fairly lazy grower and only use teas a few times through the season. I've never been diligent enough to make and apply weekly as I'm "supposed" to, but I've also figured that if the goal is inoculation and culturing of soil microbes, then I've already inoculated and as long as I keep living roots around, I should still have my host suite of microbes... shouldn't I?
 
fishwhistle

fishwhistle

4,686
263
I think if you have a strong soil mix,like a super soil and deriving your feed from it,the teas are not as neccesary because your soil is living already but teas do make a difference when you are using a light soil mix and feeding nutes.I do an experiment every year with plants in my yard getting extra leftover teas,this summer my room is torn apart for remodel but i have a couple small plants in my soil mix outside and the runoff from my mix is just like a damn tea so im using it to feed the lily of the nile/agapanthus.My mix this year is 1/2 my own homemade amended compost and half ocean forest that i was trying to use up,these plants just get normal irrigation water but one side gets the Runoff (tea) from my supersoil,can you tell which one?
 
IMG 20140711 084145 279
IMG 20140711 084157 831
Dunge

Dunge

2,233
263
I was spending lots of time brewing tea. It's not much work, but it is constant small tasks, like molasses additions. And tea forces me to hand water. Now that I made a manifold, watering is so much simpler and precise.
I also weigh my plants to monitor water use and replenish accordingly on 3-4 day intervals.
Spring clips grasp pot edge, string over top, fisherman's scale to measure.
DSCN4047 DSCN4048
 
Dunge

Dunge

2,233
263
Seems I neglected to post this pic on harvest day (one week ago).
Water only plant is on the left.
Both are bodacious.
DSCN4016
Another week of hanging and they should be ready to strip and weigh properly.
 
Dunge

Dunge

2,233
263
I think if you have a strong soil mix,like a super soil and deriving your feed from it,the teas are not as neccesary because your soil is living already but teas do make a difference when you are using a light soil mix and feeding nutes.I do an experiment every year with plants in my yard getting extra leftover teas,this summer my room is torn apart for remodel but i have a couple small plants in my soil mix outside and the runoff from my mix is just like a damn tea so im using it to feed the lily of the nile/agapanthus.My mix this year is 1/2 my own homemade amended compost and half ocean forest that i was trying to use up,these plants just get normal irrigation water but one side gets the Runoff (tea) from my supersoil,can you tell which one?
I can't stop thinking about your pictures.
Does the bigger plant get runoff as additional water to normal irrigation?
 
fishwhistle

fishwhistle

4,686
263
I can't stop thinking about your pictures.
Does the bigger plant get runoff as additional water to normal irrigation?
Yes,i just dump the runoff from my plant trays on it.Last year i did pretty much the same except i gave it the extra tea instead of plant runoff with pretty much the same result,i do have pretty poor soil,heavy clay.
 
infocus

infocus

117
63
I didn't really want to say anything at this point, but I've wondered just how useful constantly applying teas really is. I'm a fairly lazy grower and only use teas a few times through the season. I've never been diligent enough to make and apply weekly as I'm "supposed" to, but I've also figured that if the goal is inoculation and culturing of soil microbes, then I've already inoculated and as long as I keep living roots around, I should still have my host suite of microbes... shouldn't I?

that's my thinking..
 
K

kuz

678
63
I was spending lots of time brewing tea. It's not much work, but it is constant small tasks, like molasses additions. And tea forces me to hand water. Now that I made a manifold, watering is so much simpler and precise.
I also weigh my plants to monitor water use and replenish accordingly on 3-4 day intervals.
Spring clips grasp pot edge, string over top, fisherman's scale to measure.
View attachment 421924 View attachment 421930
Thats hardcore, weighing the plants. Maybe worms are the key, somehow encourage the mycros to flourish, the ones we pay big bucks for.
 
LexLuthor

LexLuthor

2,972
263
I honestly did not expect those results, but im kinda glad it happened lol...im gonna start guerrilla growing again and thought about bringing an ACT concentrate out once in a while for the plants, well now im not hahaa

I'll just amend the soil good enough for them to get water only, you use Caps bennies right?
 
Dunge

Dunge

2,233
263
I honestly did not expect those results, but im kinda glad it happened lol...im gonna start guerrilla growing again and thought about bringing an ACT concentrate out once in a while for the plants, well now im not hahaa

I'll just amend the soil good enough for them to get water only, you use Caps bennies right?

I was using caps in my tea brews, but now am using the foliar as a external preventative.
I'm happy about these results too, as I much prefer water only.
This little test is not the last word on the subject.
It just tells me, that in my soil, tea is not required.
 
Dunge

Dunge

2,233
263
Whats your soil mix? If its not proprietary lol

I have experimented with telling the formula to people who are not interested in plants, but they just loose interest no matter how much I tart up the story.
Seems dirt is just not very interesting to some people.

Check out my nine soil side by side that is currently two weeks into flower.
https://www.thcfarmer.com/community/threads/six-super-soil-variants-run-side-by-side.63549/
Originally named a six soil test, it became a a nine when I did a cutting inventory and found three more of my favorite Alien Rock Candy plants.
This tea test was done on my current 'standard' soil, which is #2.

ProMix
EWC
compost
blood meal
bone meal
high P bat guano

Exact quantities and trade name sources are specified and modified in the test thread.

At this writing, the shocking results are starting to look like it doesn't much matter what I put in the blend.
Two weeks into flower, and each plant looks like all the others, but for a few miner observations.

So check out the thread.
@greyarea has thousands of reads of his thread in less time than it has taken me to generate a few hundred.
Sure, he has mad skills, giant plants, and cool attachments.

On the other hand, my readers get to plow through bad photography, rotated images, stilted writing, and misspellings.

Extra credit here of effort?
 
Tnelz

Tnelz

4,053
263
I brew an alfalfa tea one gallon at a time for four days between watering and continue to harvest.
One little fish tank bubbler, inoculated with caps, and fed molasses.
Looks awesome bro and great experiment. Just food for thought. I'd be worried about the alfalfa tea in later bloom stages due to the nitrogen content. I would think u wouldn't c much difference but on a general overall health id say the tea plants would be better. However I'd worry that alfalfa in late bloom would actually work against u. I'm no expert and u seem to be quite good at ur craft bro just throwing it out there. Good luck!
 
Medusa

Medusa

Trichome Engineer
Supporter
4,713
263
I think if you have a strong soil mix,like a super soil and deriving your feed from it,the teas are not as neccesary because your soil is living already but teas do make a difference when you are using a light soil mix and feeding nutes.I do an experiment every year with plants in myThe second pic yard getting extra leftover teas,this summer my room is torn apart for remodel but i have a couple small plants in my soil mix outside and the runoff from my mix is just like a damn tea so im using it to feed the lily of the nile/agapanthus.My mix this year is 1/2 my own homemade amended compost and half ocean forest that i was trying to use up,these plants just get normal irrigation water but one side gets the Runoff (tea) from my supersoil,can you tell which one?
the second pic getting the tea?
 
Dunge

Dunge

2,233
263
THIS JUST IN

water only 63 g
tea only 81 g

What's that, over 20% better bud production with tea?

Rethinking the results of this test.
The plants looked identically sized at harvest, and the harvest wet weight was almost the same.
To get over 20% more bud after two week cure is shocking.

Now I am forced to work tea into my watering system.
Oh joy.
 
Dunge

Dunge

2,233
263
Nice test. Did I you post your tea recipe?
I brew an alfalfa tea one gallon at a time for four days between watering and continue to harvest.
One little fish tank bubbler, inoculated with caps, and fed molasses.
This is what I posted, but it looks a little thin, what with a result like this.
There was an active tea thread not long ago that I used to devise my method.
It's in line with my stacking worm bin into which I put kitchen scraps, and tea solids.
The worms swarm fresh additions.
Fluid runoff from the worm bin is mixed with tea just before application.
The tea itself is a fist full of alfalfa, pinch of kelp, big pinch of neem meal, and a small spoon of Caps (alternate formulations).
Fill to one gallon and drop in bubbler stone.
Prep cup of sugar water with large dollop of molasses.
Make one addition (small glug) of Alaska Morbloom.
Make daily additions of molasses from dilution cup.
Make additions of Alaska Fish Fertilizer as needed to suppress foam on the theory that foam consists of chemicals I wish to have in the bodies of my tea microbes or at least suspended in the fluid.
All of my tea efforts have focused on building a richly populated microbial soup.
Molasses additions are guided by my wish to avoid causing a yeast bloom.
I have a microscope, and have spent many hours exploring the world of microbial tea.
I enjoy many of the creatures I have come to recognize.
I like my bacteria motile, more fun to watch.
The snake is very thin, and tremendously long.(and agile)
Flounder (or flying leaf) are thought to be anaerobic and thus less desirable.
The strange thing is that after years of brewing tea, and countless hours at the microscope, I feel constantly presented with changing populations.
And they don't seem to follow a predictable sequence.
So I strive for maximum bio density and maximum diversity.
Then I let them fight it out with the soil ecosystem.
This result has revitalized my interest in tea. I now need to learn how and when to use it.
"All the time" is the default I landed on.
Lots of logic behind tapering off late in flower to promote senescence.
DSCN4063
The solids.
DSCN4066
The inoculates. (Gnatrol {BTi} in the jar is added before use as needed)
DSCN4064
Worm world & tea factory.
(note feed grade molasses)
DSCN4065
The lab.
 
Seamaiden

Seamaiden

Living dead girl
23,596
638
Have you scoped the teas before and after the addition of the Morbloom?
Looks awesome bro and great experiment. Just food for thought. I'd be worried about the alfalfa tea in later bloom stages due to the nitrogen content. I would think u wouldn't c much difference but on a general overall health id say the tea plants would be better. However I'd worry that alfalfa in late bloom would actually work against u. I'm no expert and u seem to be quite good at ur craft bro just throwing it out there. Good luck!
Not the N, the triacontanol. ;)
 
Seamaiden

Seamaiden

Living dead girl
23,596
638
I would be concerned about the P depressing fungal growth. :)
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom