MIMedGrower
- 17,190
- 438
And to be honest there are not a many alkaline sources in the nutrients we use. So a buffered soil usually keeps its ph for as long as a grow goes atleast. Usually the issue is just that the makeups of fertalizer we use are generally acidic.
I agree with ya. Nutrients are generally acidic enough. It all depends on how you buffer the soil. High alkaline water source little bit of lime. Using RO you gonna need more. I think another reason ppl see different soil pH with same products. That and the same label doesn't mean it's going to be from the same batch.
Yup dropped out at 16 moved out and went to work.
Yeah I was gonna mention with the exception of silica. That's pretty alkaline
That may work for you, but as I've explained before my waters 8.9 out the tap, can't use it that high, plants don't like it
I haven't had my pH go below 6.1 in about a year or more, ever since I started using the citric acid instead of the commercial products
Yeah I agree here. I would rather build a soil to my source water and nutrients. Far more reliable and stable than using a ph down to try to change the ph in the soil
Can't ever learn enoughYup dropped out at 16 moved out and went to work. Regretting since but I never stopped loving learning.. only thing is I learn about what I want. When I retire I'm prob going back to school
Yeah I can see why it works for ya. You don't wanna be mixing nutrients in water at that ph. Citric acid breaks down very quick with bicarbonate and in general so doesn't really affect the soil pH at all. Why I feel like citric is good for soil because it's keeps the ph in range to mix nutrients well but doesn't last long at all. Once it's in the soil... The soil does the work for phThat may work for you, but as I've explained before my waters 8.9 out the tap, can't use it that high, plants don't like it
I haven't had my pH go below 6.1 in about a year or more, ever since I started using the citric acid instead of the commercial products
Never... Knowledge is power and thats absolute truth in all forms of power. Be it knowing your rights or fixing a car.Can't ever learn enough
Can't ever learn enough
I've never paid anyone to fix anythingNever... Knowledge is power and thats absolute truth in all forms of power. Be it knowing your rights or fixing a car.
Lol that's sounds like meI've never paid anyone to fix anythingif I don't know I'm gonna damn sure spend 12 hours understanding some blueprints or a diagram. The more I read the more I understand.
Good explanation but i must say to your last comment “not always”.
You must take alkalinity in to account. Most water alone unless extremely alkaline or acidic will not change the ph of a buffered potting soil no matter how much you pour through.
If you constantly add acid to water that doesnt need acidifying eventually it will build up and acidify the medium. Same goes for ph up. If you use ph up regularly it is like adding a bit of lime (calcium) to the pot every time and eventually it will build up and raise medium ph.
Much better advice to know the alkalinity of our source water and how it reacts with our medium and nutrients and adjust or not from there.
It is also more advisable to add nutrients to tap water in an amount that gets the final ph in range for proper uptake. Than to constantly adjust an improper mixture.
And really for very alkaline water (hard) it is better to mix down to 150 ppm with ro filtered water than to add acid to neutralize the calcium.
Not the way I intended it. Intended to say ph of RO is irrelevant. And alkalinity is an important consideration of ph. So many growers have issues with ph and much of the time that's due to alkalinity. Most new growers are not even aware of alkalinity or its role when looking at all these ph measurements.Yea, I agree with what you saying here, and I'm doing exactly that. I used to adjust the water every time (ie. 2 drops of phosphoric acid solution) and yes, I agree, that's probably counter productive, (I stopped doing this recently) as my plant medium becomes more acidic over the long haul. So I stopped doing it.
I guess what I objected to mostly, was someone suggesting that "pH" was irrelevant, and that you should only look at the water source. For many here, that might not be a viable option for them, and while I'll agree the water source is paramount to excellent results, testing pH is an overall good practice, (usually lacking among newer growers) and is cardinal to refining and developing basic skills, (ie. lot's of practice) It should be encouraged, not diminished, or marginalized.
Yeah I agree here. I would rather build a soil to my source water and nutrients. Far more reliable and stable than using a ph down to try to change the ph in the soil
Hey I appreciate the honest feedback bro... I think your right after rereading it. I'm pretty tied up to sit down and think till next week but I agree I can clean it up a bit. Afterall it was intended to be a simple easy to understand explanation. So if I can make it better than it will serve ppl better.Yea, I think simple is good. And I want to make it very clear here, your certainly a far more advance grower than I, that said. I've spent most of my life writing on a daily basis, in the medical profession, and conveying information, though documentation.
I've have the same issues, you've got a lot of thoughts, and your trying to get them out there. Brevity, using concise and exact words can be challenging, but extremely effective. Don't be afraid to go back, and cut some things out, ie. (edit) it might help you focus your thoughts, to hone in on the main issues your trying to convey.
Don't worry about word structure or transition words, either, it means very little in this sort of stuff.
Yeah I'm in that boat.I still think almost every ph comment for soil grows is actually excess nute buildup.
New growers need a ph and ppm meter. Without both measurements we are just guessing.
Good info. Did not know that.I would suggest azomite, as an amendment for soil, for buffering ph. I've started using it recently and it's simply amazing.
Azomite is hydrated sodium calcium aluminosilicate derived from a natural volcanic mineral deposit. ... I has a ph of 8 (somewhat alkaline) but it doesn't seem to raise or lower ph in soil, but it should work as an excellent buffer to reduce the chances of over acidity.
Good info. Did not know that.
Oh I thought that's what he said it doesn't affect ph. Ah I see the last sentence. Reading comprehension Aqua Man reading comprehensionNo the faq i copied above says it does not raise ph so it isnt a buffer just a source of trace elements.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?