QleanerQuest
- Posts
- 1,480
- Reactions
- 3,279
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2009
- Points
- 263
thanks for imput lady goods......Hey soser... Hope your week's going well. Looking forward to your pics. I know it's a matter of preference for some, but I don't cut my upper fan leaves. I just tuck them back out of the way @ lights on. That way, to whatever extent, they're still able to do what they do. Also, I was under the impression that the asymmetrical branching was a sign of the plant's maturity.
Maybe we can get Meeks in here to do some 'splainin.:D
I hear you bro , some def gotta go as this girl is a beast.... thanks for stopping by and helping out bro... much appreciated ...peace soseri prune some, tuck away whatever you can...some just gotta go imo
Love & Light,
~Sox
You want to get a CO2 monitor/regulator. They aren't cheap. I think there is one out these days that doesn't give you an extremely accurate reading, but does the job and is around $60-100?Well got another question i picked up a co2 tank titan brand and until this point I have been using ghetto co2 in my room (sugar water & yeast in big bottles- shaken numerous times) ok well i started using it this morning thou i am not really sure wtf I am doing , step 1 - plug tank in step 2 - turn tank on step 3- insert tube into room co2 enters room .. question is ?? how long should i be keeping the co2 flowing and at what level ... my current flower space is a closet that is 4ft by 4ft and 10ft high ..... this morning at lights on i ran it for ten mins and at lights off another ten mins.... I should be connecting this to a timer correct ? and I should not keep the tank in the closet because of heat ? any info would be appreciated and picture updates tomorrow will be a full 2 weeks into flowering .......Peace SoSer
I believe there is one on the side of the tank , I will post up a picture of it and see ... I'm totally ignorant to this co2 stuff and about as unhandy as they come but sure can grow some pretty flowers...... thanks nmeeks again !!!!! Respect SoSerYou want to get a CO2 monitor/regulator. They aren't cheap. I think there is one out these days that doesn't give you an extremely accurate reading, but does the job and is around $60-100?
Appreciate your insights, Meeks. It was useful getting the technical side of how the fan leaves work. Thanks for taking the time.Hey Soser, your question was brought to my attention by Lady Goods and so hopefully I can explain a little about what I know, which might help you decide what to do about the leaves shading parts of your plant.
...
I hope this made sense, I wrote half of it while I was in my Botany lab so I may have gone on some unnecessary tangents or skipped over somethings. . . but just let me know if you need me to explain something further.
-Meeks
I can't speak in very much detail about what issues might be caused for a plant in regards to cutting fan leaves to reduce surface area during flower. I can say that the reason you do it on clones is to reduce transpiration because the clone has no root system to start, so any water lost isn't gonna come back very soon. My thinking is that you would definitely not want that effect on a flowering plant, because transpiration from the leaves is the only reason the roots are taking up water and nutrients in the first place! Think about the vascular system like a straw, as the water is pulled out of the stomata on the underside of the leaves, the water inside the plant is pulled up the stem coming from the roots, and the water pulled out of the roots is osmotically replaced by the water in the media. So if you reduce transpiration, you reduce the amount of water being pulled into the plant also, which means less nutrients are being taken up and hence reduced yield/growth.Wow, incredible information nmeeks , I understand exactly what you mean , Thou I did have to read it twice to let it sink (no pun intended) . Makes perfect sense I did realize that the leaves made sugar that generated the bud growth but not to the extent to explained it to me. Boy would I love to smoke up with you one day and pick your brain for all that knowledge bro... I greatly APPRECIATE you taking the time to explain that to me in the detail you did. It was awesome of you to be that concerned with my issue ...... Your the man nmeeks..... best to you and yours .... I will be printing it out and going over it a few more times but seems perfectly logical. This is the reason that most prune there plant up from the bottom as these leaves are doing nothing but taking away from production on the top of the plant a lesson that took me awhile to come to terms with as in the beginning I believed all buds are good buds no matter the size not realizing it was hurting me in the long run. I def need to look into Horticulture class as I can read this kind of stuff all day...... um so your saying that the larger leaves on top of the plant are actually sources so they should not be removed but what is your (wanna say feeling but ) knowledge fits better on cutting them along the edges. Like when making clones. Can you give me some info on this when you get a moment. You typed alot for me today (espec during class time) so when you get a free moment is fine. I have already removed the lower leaves for clones and pruning the bottom and was told that day 21 and day 42 are the best times to remove the remaining cumbersome leaves .... once again thank you very much bro.......
Removing fan leaves entirely is much safer (in regards to infection) for the plant than cutting a leaf in half to reduce surface area. The plant develops a natural layer called the abscision layer right at the point where the petiole of the fan leaf meets the stem, which is why u may have noticed older leaves always have a clean break at the stem. The abscision layer is to help close up the wound before it even occurs, so removing leaves by breaking them off at the base of the petiole exposes much fewer unprotected cells than cutting a leaf in the middle of a leaf blade.It's all debatable I guess. I defoliate and it doesn't decrease my yield at all. Nor have I ever had a plant get an infection. If anything it increases the amount of usable nugs. I have WAY less larfy buds when I open up the canopy a bit by removing fans. Just don't go nuts and over do it. I remove big fans that are covering any other buds otherwise the shaded buds stay lime green and don't develop fully which renders them useless.
cool would be interested in pictures , I got my 21 and 42 day info from Alien and obviously nmeeks has explained which ones to remove , thanks for responcse and swinging by.... Much Appreciated.. Peace SoSerI'm a big fan of defoliation. There is no set time of when it's best to do it. You have to read your plant, and apply what nMeeks was explaining (which was a GREAT explanation BTW, props to nMeeks!). If you look at my Eskimo Kush grow, you'll see I removed almost all fan leaves on her. I can get you before and after pics if you'd like. I just didn't post them in the thread because I know how much controversy defoliation brings to the table, so I just do it and don't really look for opinions on whether I should or not. My ARC is actually due for defoliation now. I'll get before and afters of that as well.
Thanks for taking the time to get nmeeks facts for me, really smart guy with good info.... your great Goods... Respect SoSerAppreciate your insights, Meeks. It was useful getting the technical side of how the fan leaves work. Thanks for taking the time.
Makes sence to me nmeeks great info as always .... I will be removing the sink leaves in about 6 days and today was the beginning of day 15 and the buds have doubled in size , they are now picture worthy will get some up today for sure..............Blessings SoSerI can't speak in very much detail about what issues might be caused for a plant in regards to cutting fan leaves to reduce surface area during flower. I can say that the reason you do it on clones is to reduce transpiration because the clone has no root system to start, so any water lost isn't gonna come back very soon. My thinking is that you would definitely not want that effect on a flowering plant, because transpiration from the leaves is the only reason the roots are taking up water and nutrients in the first place! Think about the vascular system like a straw, as the water is pulled out of the stomata on the underside of the leaves, the water inside the plant is pulled up the stem coming from the roots, and the water pulled out of the roots is osmotically replaced by the water in the media. So if you reduce transpiration, you reduce the amount of water being pulled into the plant also, which means less nutrients are being taken up and hence reduced yield/growth.
All that technical jumbo is basically my way of saying that smaller leaves or larger leaves that have then been cut to be smaller, will lead to reduced yield. The question you have to answer for yourself because I don't know for sure, is 'would the reduction in transpiration be worth the increase in photosynthesis on the leaves currently being shaded'. My thoughts are most likely not, but I have other factors that worry me about that idea too.
Consider that when you cut those leaf blades to have less surface area to reduce the shading they are causing on lower areas, what you are really doing is exposing plant tissue that will be unprotected by its natural epidermal cuticle (just as any plant wound would be unprotected) and therefore runs the higher risk of infection from a plant pathogen possibly causing disease! That right there is enough to make me stay away from the idea, but like I said, I have no formal knowledge of that practice and its possible Pros/Cons. . .
Hope this helps and doesn't just make the decision that much harder.
Oh, and thanks to everyone for the kind words, I appreciate the interest in the science not just the practical.
-Meeks
Cool thanks for stopping by and giving your imput Delae , it is a well respected one coming from such a terrific grower as yourself , check back will picture update today. Peace Brotha.... SoSerIt's all debatable I guess. I defoliate and it doesn't decrease my yield at all. Nor have I ever had a plant get an infection. If anything it increases the amount of usable nugs. I have WAY less larfy buds when I open up the canopy a bit by removing fans. Just don't go nuts and over do it. I remove big fans that are covering any other buds otherwise the shaded buds stay lime green and don't develop fully which renders them useless.
Nice BudM .... needed a good laugh to start my day , that and I will kill for caffiene currently , need my monster rehab bad .....I Pluck It!:D
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?