Jmaes Mabley
- 709
- 143
I respect your opinion, but I'll stick to the diagnosis made by professional growers.From what I’ve read, there appears to be a higher frequency in the northern and northeastern zones and affects primarily outdoor grows. I’ve only come across two incidence of it occurring with indoor plants. The timing of symptoms is very consistent as well. End of July/early August is when the majority of reports are made. Same time as the plants transition to flower and why it’s often assumed the issue is related to a P deficiency. One issue is most growers don’t report back after harvest so we are left wondering how the plants were ultimately affected. We would have a better idea of what’s going on if there was a website/forum thread/etc that could be used for data collection.
Regarding TMV, it has been noted by the botany community that it does not exist in cannabis. People often tend to assume that any variegation/mottling with their plants is a symptom of TMV. According to the science community, there has never been a verified case of TMV in weed and any claims it does infect marijuana is a result of the stereotypical “bro-science”. Don’t shoot the messenger….
Not sure where you heard that TMV hasn't been found in cannabis. It certainly has. The Canadian government found it in cannabis.From what I’ve read, there appears to be a higher frequency in the northern and northeastern zones and affects primarily outdoor grows. I’ve only come across two incidence of it occurring with indoor plants. The timing of symptoms is very consistent as well. End of July/early August is when the majority of reports are made. Same time as the plants transition to flower and why it’s often assumed the issue is related to a P deficiency. One issue is most growers don’t report back after harvest so we are left wondering how the plants were ultimately affected. We would have a better idea of what’s going on if there was a website/forum thread/etc that could be used for data collection.
Regarding TMV, it has been noted by the botany community that it does not exist in cannabis. People often tend to assume that any variegation/mottling with their plants is a symptom of TMV. According to the science community, there has never been a verified case of TMV in weed and any claims it does infect marijuana is a result of the stereotypical “bro-science”. Don’t shoot the messenger….
You obviously know a great deal about soil science. I appreciate your opinion. Sounds like you most likely have a degree in soil science? I do as well. If that's the case you certainly know that Boron deficiency's are super rare, and almost never dramatically impact plant health. You also know that trace amounts of boron would cure any potential B deficiency's. Many fertilizers contain trace amounts of B.That purple top is just -B, with colder nights. As is all the "varegation" and practically every other leaf symptom prominently featured on weed growing websites. Poly hybrid = poly symptoms and 9999.9999 % of pot growers miss them all.
To be honest I've always assumed it's a law you can only show boron deficient Cannabis online. It's all I see every time I log in.
"I'm not sure exactly how Si helps, but coupled with K it does seem to help. Read the article I linked. It will surprise you guys easy the virus is spread around."
It works by antagonizing the CaCO3 that's locking out B. Of course the mythical "virus" spreads easily. You're growing multiple plants with the same poor soil/nutrients/water, right? And ignoring a dozen B symptoms leading up to the drastic color change, right?
View attachment 1272400
Polyhybrid, poly symptoms, same cause. The "pros" in Cali are starting in soils <5.5pH to avoid this problem, since they are forced to pay for hard water instead of stealing clean water like they used to, in the good ol med days when Cali bud was still green. Cannabis consultants and soil producers are dumping so much shit in people's fields attempting to battle this problem.
Increased cytosolic CaCO3 contributes to Hydrogen-rich water, promoting anthocyanin, instead of natural Cannabis antioxidant (thiols). With a lack of base cations you are seeing an increase in H that eventually transfers to the plant, dropping sap pH:
View attachment 1272406
When sap pH hits 6.4, you'll get fungal symptoms, which somehow reinforces the notion that this isn't a nutrient problem. When you've locked out B, you've probably locked out K also. Adding K without B will cause different -B symptoms, namely the "variegation".
Pot growers today, will generally do ANYTHING but grow healthy plants. I don't get it. All the pesticides and shit to harvest bad crops.. You can tell who took the vaccine instead of eating healthy... I never worry about things like that, because nutrition isn't a myth in my world, all the imaginary boogie men are.
I really believe this is a virus. This doesn't line up with B deficiency at all. It's a fairly new phenomenon. If it were a B deficiency, people would've seen this a long, long time ago and B fertilization would be common place. Trace amounts of B cure B deficiency's. I'd be willing to bet one of your fertilizers has B in it.Its not cold. Night time temps are in the mid 70s. We use Promix BX, same thing we use indoors, and never have this problem. Our soil PH is the same inside, and out. Feed is the same. Only thing different is ne is grown inside, and the other outside. Ive been growing weed since 1972, and never had this problen until 8 years ago. It alkso does happen in the native soil, but the soil is good, ph is correct, and is the same growing technique Ive used for 50 years.
This problem has nothing to do with cold. It aint cld in the middle of summer. I also totally agree with Seawood that the problem really starts to show itself at the end of July, and early August, right before they start to flower, and very early flower.
I lso am very healthy, and havent had one sip of cola since 1978. I run 40 miles a week, and liift weights 4-5 days a week. In the 80s I ran a 2:38 marathon, and have run at least 8 Ultramarathons in under 7 hours. I was 1985 AAU Kentucky Powerlifting champ at 148lbs with a 1350lbs total. My training partner was a former world record holder in the Squat in 1988 at 242lbs. He Squatted 813lbs.
I eat no white flour products. No preservatives, artificial colors or flavors. I cook all my food in either reverse osmosis water, or distilled water, and have since 1978. At 64 years of age, I can still o 20 thumbs only pushups. Whits fingers pointed, and not in fist. I still run a 5:30 mile. Can still double my bodyweight on bench. And easily Deadlift, and Squat 400lbs. I run 20 something years old guys off. Many of them much bigger than me.
So I know what it is to eat healthy. And I know this problem isnt caused by the cold, or PH. This never happens inside, using the same soil/Promix BX. Its PH is 6.2.
And Ive had all 4 shots for flu, and have never had it, but have been exposed more times than I can count. I also wer an N95 mask. Have only eaten out in a restaurant 3 times in over 4 years. One buddy had a stroke before there was a vaccine. Was on a vent for 40 days. In a nursing home for 8 months. When he went home, he still has occpational therapt a,d physical therapy come to his home 3x a week. He still cant drive, and has a tracheostomy to breathe. Hes still really fucked up. I also know several other people that have permanent damage from flu. And my wife is an ICU nurse at the VA Hospital in Huntington Wv for 10 years.
I respect your opinion, but I'll stick to the diagnosis made by professional growers.
Yes our fertilizer does. Azomite. Its got over 70 trace minerals. Boron being one. . Its also readily available to the plant. Breaks down in less than 2 weeks. They even feed it to feed stock.I really believe this is a virus. This doesn't line up with B deficiency at all. It's a fairly new phenomenon. If it were a B deficiency, people would've seen this a long, long time ago and B fertilization would be common place. Trace amounts of B cure B deficiency's. I'd be willing to bet one of your fertilizers has B in it.
I get it. Forums are full of so much misinformation. I don't blame you for being skeptical at all. After reading some of the stuff on these forums,I certainly am as well.You’d take the word of grower with no factual, lab-based evidence vs a university graduate specializing in plant science/botany? Professional growers aren’t scientists. I’m not trying to start a pissing match as I have no dog in this fight…but as a logical, fact-based person, I’ll gravitate to the science vs speculation every time. Just because someone “claims” something to be the case doesn’t make it true without proof.
I’m not saying you are right or wrong regarding your theories on TMV or this purple top thing, I’m just a skeptic by nature and the amount of research I’ve put into this condition has only led to more questions and very little as far as answers. Your logic is sound and makes a lot of sense. No disrespect intended.
An example of misinformation on a different forum…someone claimed this purple top condition was Beet Curly Top Virus and had others convinced. I don’t know what this purpling condition is but I know it’s not BCTV. This is a prime example of how bad info can get out of control.
I noticed that I added the 3rd pic in error.I don’t know if or how this affects the discussion but:
I have two northern lights fem growing from seeds.
Both were nice and green Monday 8/15
I’ll attach pics in order.
Still green 8/17 morning, I was planning to flush them because they just had a few feedings in a row and I was getting nervous about over doing it.
The flush was more work than I had time for, so only got one finished.
It immediately looked purple in the buds.
Today, 8/19, it’s way worse, but only on the one which received the flush.
I did follow the flush with a light feeding of fox farms boomerang.
I hope that the pictures show up in correct chronological order.
View attachment 1272652
Could be phosphorus deficiency. This purple disease thing usually shows it's ugly face in early pre flower.I noticed that I added the 3rd pic in error.
It's a different plant. It's right next to the affected plant, touching, but it's a Forbidden Fruit.
To muddy things further, it also received a flush, same process, but hasn't shown any problems.
It's easily twice the size of the Northern Lights plants and about 30 days older.
They are all growing in an enclosed balcony, but should be considered outdoors as they have air flow directly from the outside.
I thought as much (not that I'm that smart, but I've seen others hypothesize such), so I did a foliar feed on the lower leaves with FF Big Bloom (0-0.5-0.7).Could be phosphorus deficiency. This purple disease thing usually shows it's ugly face in early pre flower.
Definitely symptomatic of P deficiency. That's what I thought at first. The pictures look similar to what everyone else is showing, and it's definitely not P deficient. Someone on here, who is obviously highly educated in soil science believes it to be a Boron deficiency. Imo, it's a virus of some sort. I've seen similar scenarios in turf management. For whatever reason, new biotic stressors show up inexplicably. It takes years, and many people having similar issues, to finally diagnose the problem. This seems to be a trustfully new phenomenon which leads me to believe it isn't a nutrient deficiency that many, many people are all experiencing at the same time. Too coincidental. It's some sort of biotic stress. I don't believe it's fungal or bacterial. All the symptoms point to viral. This is my opinion, but I have solid secondary opinions from well established agricultural and cannabis professionals. Viruses have been detected in cannabis before. I'm am currently looking into pathology labs for potential diagnosis. It's getting to crush time so hopefully I can send something early next week. Viruses are notoriously difficult to diagnose so we'll see.Could be phosphorus deficiency. This purple disease thing usually shows it's ugly face in early pre flower.
This is sorta what I think may be happening. I think the cannabis pathologists have some work to do. Just to rule out B deficiency, I treated a plant today with some Boron. I really don't think that's it, but it wouldn't be the first time I was wrong.You make some great points. Hard to argue with that logic.
On a side note, I did read one report where a sample of this purple top disorder was sent to a lab for testing. I believe it was tested for approximately 30 viruses/pathogens/phytoplasmas and all came back negative. I have no idea how this testing works but it may may not mean much if they can’t test for a disease they aren’t aware of, which may be the case with this purple top thing.
Regardless, hopefully people who are experiencing this issue will report back post-harvest.
Really interesting fertilizer. I've heard of it before but never used it. I don't know anything about it. I will say many products like this rely on microbial degradation so they are long term products. The downfall to microbial dependant fertilizers is that you're actually crushing you're soil biology. Instead of feeding microbes you're making them work. A proliferation of soil microbes will always return free N, and those microbes form a symbiotic relationship with plants. This is pure speculation but those would be questions I would want answered.Yes our fertilizer does. Azomite. Its got over 70 trace minerals. Boron being one. . Its also readily available to the plant. Breaks down in less than 2 weeks. They even feed it to feed stock.
Azomite has 29 ppm of Boron. 65.8 ppm of Silicon.
Mineral Analysis Element Analysis con’t. ppm Alumina, Al2O3 11.43% Gold, Au 0.005 Barium oxide, BaO 0.09% Hafnium, Hf 21 Calcium oxide, CaO 3.67% Holmium, Ho 0.6 Carbon, C 0.61% Indium, In 0.01 Chlorine, Cl 0.22% Iodine, I 2.2 Hydrogen, H 0.38% Lead, Pb 6.2 Magnesium oxide, MgO 0.78% Lithium, Li 859 Manganese oxide, MnO2 0.02% Lutetium, Lu 0.5 Nitrogen, N 0.15% Mercury, Hg 0.01 Oxygen, O 0.73% Molybdenum, Mo 12.6 Phosphorus pentoxide, P2O5 0.15% Neodymium, Nd 5.1 Potassium oxide, K2O 5.23% Nickel, Ni 2.6 Silicon dioxide, SiO2 65.85% Niobium, Nb 40 Sodium oxide, Na2O 2.07% Palladium, Pd 0.008 Strontium oxide, SrO 0.03% Praseodymium, Pr 27 Sulfur trioxide, SO3 0.21% Rhenium, Re 0.011 Titanium dioxide, TiO2 0.20% Rhodium, Rh 0.002 Loss on Incineration 6.43% Rubidium, Rb 325 Ruthenium, Ru 0.013 Additional Element Analysis ppm Samarium, Sm 6.2 Antimony, Sb 0.4 Scandium, Sc 2.7 Arsenic, As 1.1 Selenium, Se 0.7 Beryllium, Be 3.3 Silver, Ag 0.005 Bismuth, Bi 3.5 Strontium, Sr 380 Boron, B 29 Sulfur, S 240 Bromine, Br 6.6 Tantalum, Ta 2.7 Cadmium, Cd 0.3 Tellurium, Te 0.022 Cerium, Ce 230 Terbium, Tb 0.8 Cesium, Cs 21.7 Thallium, Tl 5.9 Chromium, Cr 6.1 Thorium, Th 180 Cobalt, Co 22.3 Thulium, Tm 0.6 Copper, Cu 12 Tin, Sn 2.9 Dysprosium, Dy 2.7 Tungsten, W 26 Erbium, Er 1.7 Uranium, U 4 Europium, Eu 3.7 Vanadium, V 7.8 Fluorine, F 900 Ytterbium, Yb 1.4 Gadolinium, Gd 3.7 Yttrium, Y 23 Gallium, Ga 15 Zinc, Zn 64.3 Germanium, Ge 6.1 Zirconium, Zr 62.7
I was thinking P deficiency because he did a flush and washed everything out of the media (see his posts). I do realize the virus is not deficiency. cheersDefinitely symptomatic of P deficiency. That's what I thought at first. The pictures look similar to what everyone else is showing, and it's definitely not P deficient. Someone on here, who is obviously highly educated in soil science believes it to be a Boron deficiency. Imo, it's a virus of some sort. I've seen similar scenarios in turf management. For whatever reason, new biotic stressors show up inexplicably. It takes years, and many people having similar issues, to finally diagnose the problem. This seems to be a trustfully new phenomenon which leads me to believe it isn't a nutrient deficiency that many, many people are all experiencing at the same time. Too coincidental. It's some sort of biotic stress. I don't believe it's fungal or bacterial. All the symptoms point to viral. This is my opinion, but I have solid secondary opinions from well established agricultural and cannabis professionals. Viruses have been detected in cannabis before. I'm am currently looking into pathology labs for potential diagnosis. It's getting to crush time so hopefully I can send something early next week. Viruses are notoriously difficult to diagnose so we'll see.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?