Yeah, ok. I've been reading and reading the responses in this thread and was debating, do I respond to this one, to that one?
The angle from which you're hitting this is totally reminding me of the debate over whether or not one should be riding a motorcycle. And to me it's a matter of calculated risks. I can calculate my risk riding fairly accurately. However, with many of the pesticides we're discussing here, the calculations can
not be made so accurately. But I get what you're saying and to a large degree have to agree, those are salient questions and we can't disconnect ourselves from them simply because they don't fit our paradigm.
The one instance of spider mites I experienced were with mites that came from SoCal.
Floramite and
Forbid don't
touch them. A single application of
Avid did it, but at the very same time I was learning that high humidity coupled with low temperatures completely disallows their establishment
in the first place. Now, I can't recommend doing that with flowering girls, the results are disappointing (of high RH + low temps <68F) to say the least. But for vegging plants it could likely eradicate those that make their way in.
As far as misuse and overuse, I say let's spread the love to include all homeowners who immediately slap Round-Up on those weeds, Scott's on the lawn Miracle Grow on their flowers, and just peruse the pesticide aisle at Lowe's, Home de Pot, ACE, True Value... they're extensive for a reason (interestingly enough, Bayer of all manu's, has come out with their Natria line of "safe" 'cides'). They also can't stand bugs of any sort for the most part and are very likely to also be using high amounts of anti-microbial/antibiotic products. These people tend to be sick frequently and prone to allergies as well, but I'm seriously digressing.
This
all, specifically for me, goes back to the ideas and musings of what will happen in the future. With earth, with life, etcetera.
We humans will suffer our own ultimate demise in one of two ways--we will
either pollute ourselves off the face of the earth (less and less likely), OR we will create a superbug (becoming more and more likely, already done with glyphosate) that will wipe us or our main foodstuffs off the face of the earth.
Now, who's ready to line up to contribute to that?
I think I can do my small part, and it starts with my bit of the earth. I won't use glyphosate anymore. I won't use pesticides outside at all. I leave most of the weeds and native flora and fauna in situ. It's mellow if it's yellow and now if it's yellow it's going into the garden and on the plants, not into the septic system. I leave my home (driving) at most about 1x/week, and now that we're getting the solar array I may very well sell my scoot and get an electric car. Or, I may go full-blown hippie and retreat into the woods, I don't know yet.
The question to me isn't whether or not it's happening, it's about MY ROLE.
I can't change the world, but I can change me and my little part in it.
Aaahhh! That's where the disconnect is happening, now I see it! That's the caveat, Buddy, you just said it yourself. IF YOU KILL THEM ALL.
And that's the rub with a lot, if not all of these products--kill rate is rarely 100%. If it were (globally, w/all 'cides'), no organism would be able to develop resistance. I don't think we monkeys are quite that clever yet. Some things do have a 100% kill rate. Steam can be a 100% kill rate in certain applications, for instance, which is why it's actually
better to use for, say, home cleaning.
You can't assume that everyone kills them all. You may be able to assume such for yourself, but I, and others, don't know if this is an erroneous assumption or not, as we're really only going by the electrons you're throwing out here for us. As far as NPS strips go, the minute you experience mites laughing at them is the moment you'll pick up what others have been puttin' down. I find they kill
most fungus gnats fairly effectively (closet grow), but they don't kill them all.
This could... maybe
should, simply spawn another thread--Why do we care about the environment?